You can probably buy a dedicated Pentium 1 laptop with RS-232 for the same price as the RS-232 to USB cable. Unless you can find one for free, or kept your old systems. <humor> I even have a Sinclair ZX-81 with an external RS-232 adapter, but it doesn't do Windoze. It was the first "glass teletype" I owned though. </humor> --- In ComputerVoltageSources@yahoogroups.com, "Michael A. Firman" <maf@...> wrote: > > > I think that John's point was that RS232 Serial connectors > are outmoded and generally less and less available as standard > i/o devices on computers (even PCs), despite the fact that USB > may be overkill for this application. This is (or will be when > it is realized), however, a hobbyist project, so RS232 is perfectly > applicable here (and adding the USB logic would be way too > complicated). > > I do agree with John on the point that RS232 shouldn't be considered > for a production (read commercial) device. > > BTW all USB->RS232 adapters are not equal they fall into several > categories based upon the controller devices they use. Even those > that use the same controller devices can have slightly different > Configuration Descriptors/Device Decriptors/Interface Descriptors/ > Endpoint Descriptors causing the software that drives them on the > host to do all sorts of different (and sometimes wacky) things. > > --- In ComputerVoltageSources@yahoogroups.com, "Grant Richter" > <grichter@> wrote: > > > > I am pretty sure the Renasas part just sets up a standard "tickle > me" for Flash config. During > > power up sequencing it probably blits something out a port pin and > IF it gets a response, > > then switches to a Flash load mode. It was probably designed for > JTAG and they just tacked > > RS-232 level translators on the JTAG pins, and set up the handshake > across RS-232, because > > it was cheaper than a JTAG dongle. > > > > USB is laughably overkill for loading 32K of Flash. But info tech is > SO bloated nowadays they > > need all that bandwidth for the 4 megabytes of handshaking needed to > pass a 32K packet... > > >
Message
Re: USB vs. RS-232
2006-04-19 by Grant Richter
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.