Two big issues with electronic drums to consider would be the playability, or "feel", of the drums and the sounds from the module. I've been playing acoustic drums for 20 years and electronics for 10, and I personally prefer the feel of rubber pads to mesh heads. The harder, rubber surface seems to respond more like a real drum head than the mesh heads, especially when you consider how the drum stick responds. One caveat I would throw in is that I am not a hard hitter, so the harder response from the rubber pad probably doesn't affect my technique as much as it would someone who really likes to slam the drums. I have found that playing with double-butted sticks (no taper/bead to the stick) reduces the sharp slapback that I initially experienced playing rubber e-drums which seemed to cause wrist pain when playing for extended periods. As far as sounds, this is a highly subjective topic. To generalize my impression, the Yamaha sounds are realistic and dry, whereas the Roland sounds seem very synthetic and "wet" (lot of effects). Of course, all modules can be customized to some extent, but I have found that the DT sounds are very usable right out of the box. I've owned an Yamaha RM-50 module for 10 years, and the sounds (many of which I hear in the newer DT modules) are still very useful for recording and sequencing. To me, with the Roland V-drums I'm paying for a lot of sounds that I would never want to use. My suggestion would be to try and get some time behind the kits you're considering and evaluate which sounds suit your personal tastes/needs the best. The Yami's are definitely a good value for the money. Good luck. __________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - Helps protect you from nasty viruses. http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail
Message
Re: [DTXpress] Yamaha vs Roland
2004-10-06 by Joel DeLuna
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.