> Martin, I'm curious as to why you think posting material to a free > group from which no profit is generated violates the fair use doctrine. > I think Doug was well with in his rights, and well within the NYT's > rights. > Firstly, it most likely isn't fair use as it is defined. Or if it is, it would be a pretty tough argument to make. However, the NYTimes (like many newspapers) actually encourages and enables you to e-mail the whole article via it's website system. They don't appear to put limits on who or what you can e-mail it to (I can see nothing saying you have to email it to a single friend - for example). So, they seem to encourage the promulgating. So in this case, I think you'd have to make a pretty strong case that posting it isn't permitted. tim
Message
RE: Posting Copyrighted material was: Re: [Digital BW] "Does a Painter With a Camera Cheat?"
2002-06-17 by Tim Atherton