Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

RE: [Digital BW] Digital, film, scanning comparisons

2003-05-21 by Austin Franklin

Anthony,

> > Too much of a generalization.  You can get
> > exceptional B&W from a scanner, which most
> > all use RGB sensors.
>
> The scanner isn't the original imaging device.

Don't do this.  Your comment was, and I quote:

"But you'll never get really good black and white from any RGB
imaging device."

It says ANY RGB imaging device.  As I said, your statement was too much of a
generalization, and whether it's the original imaging device or not, it IS
an imaging device.

> > Also, scanning backs use RGB and give full
> > color data, and they convert very very well
> > to grayscale.
>
> Not as well as if they just scanned in black and white to begin with.

That is not true as an overall statement.

> > Well, if you're talking cameras, Kodak has,
> > and if you're talking scanners, the Leaf was.
>
> Kodak's camera is the rare (unique?) exception to the rule.

But it WAS and IS available.

I don't have time to waste arguing with you.

Austin

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.