Step one is a drum scanner, assuming the negatives can survive being fluid mounted. There are very expensive flatbeds from Creo, Fuji, Aztek and others. Their big claim to fame is speed. You can fill their large flat-bed full of film, and off you go. Supposedly they give higher quality than consumer flatbeds, but I have no idea if this is true. They are certainly heavier built. One potential problem with these would be getting them serviced. The a step down would be Epson and Microtek's professional models. The Microteck 1800F get's good reviews. Supposedly the optics, mechanicals and electronics are better than consumer models. It's true that dynamic range, low vibration, precision movements...are all more important that resolution. Finally, there are the consumer flatbeds. There are a number of issues involved, including the skill and care of the operator. For example, a great "consumer flatbed" scan will trump a poor drum scan.... If you get your own equipment, you'll have to add in the cost of training an operator and upkeep on the scanner. One thing to remember is that most "consumer scanner" reviews are done very poorly. It's essential to get the film holders to the ideal height, and this often isn't the manufacturer's default! Second, keeping the film flat has a huge effect on quality, just as it does when enlarging traditionally. I wet-mount on the underside of a sheet of optical glass that's been shimmed to the ideal height for my scanner. This gives much better results than using my Canon film-holders that came with the scanner. But...it's b PITA and it take a lot of time. So if you're doing a large amount of scans, as you are, this might be prohibitive. If possible, try to get a scan of the same negative on the various options.
Message
Re: [Digital BW] All you scanning pros: Great scanner for 4x5 negs?
2007-07-10 by Peter De Smidt
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.