Digital BW, The Print

Ok, I am in this club and we have a Printing day where we go and print
the images that we like and show them to the club, the person that
give the critic of the images, he like to talk about the image insted
of the Print. 

 I think that is not fare or educational, we are one more time looking
and image if you like it or not, in any moment we look at the print
and   talk about what make a print good, 

 My question to the group is.... what is the criteria for a print to
bee  a good print, ( good shadow detail, good sharpness, good middle
tone, highlight detail ) staff like that. what is your requirement list.

Thanks 

 Gabriel Fernandez