Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Thread

Lightroom: 2 preset questions

Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-07 by Lew Schwartz

1. I notice a plus sign after a preset name which I can9;t rename away. What does it mean? How did it get there?

2. Are presets additive, mutually exclusive or what? ie If I've already used a preset will using another, different preset overwrite or add to the first one?

-Lew Schwartz

Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-08 by goldner_jeff@...

1. A plus sign on one of the presets means it will be applied on import. Right click on it and see if that is checked.

2. Additive

Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-08 by goldner_jeff@...

Actually, additive is not entirely correct. Values are not additive. If a later preset changes a value that has already been set, that new value will replace the old one. For example, preset 1 has white set to +30, but preset 2 (applied later) has white set to +10, the new value will be +10. But anything not changed in a later preset will remain. So preset 1 might have black set to -20 and preset 2 doesn't change black, the result will still be -20.

Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-08 by Hal Gage

1. I notice a plus sign after a preset name which I can't rename away. What
does it mean? How did it get there?
Means the preset noted has been applied, but manually modified by you. Dbl clicking on the preset usually clears any manual deviations from the preset image and brings it back to the preset’s original settings

2. Are presets additive, mutually exclusive or what? ie If I've already
used a preset will using another, different preset overwrite or add to the
first one?
Presets are exclusive. Changing from one preset to the next cancels out the previous and applies the current.

A good resource for questions like these is Martin Evening’s Adobe Lightroom CC.

Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-09 by Myron Gochnauer

Reading this thread I felt like ranting a bit, but I'll hold it down to a few simple observations and a question:

The observations:
  • The Adobe help functions for Photoshop and Lightroom are seriously inadequate for quick information and guidance.
  • Help books for these programs have become an industry unto themselves. In attempting to be comprehensive most books make it difficult to answer specific questions that intermediate users, especially, face in the middle of a project.
  • Good help for computer programs *is* possible. Some are regrettably history - - the DOS word processor XyWrite’s early manuals were nearly perfect - - while others are limited to relatively small markets - - the text markup and formatting system LaTeX has a number of add-on help systems that are. . . well. . . helpful!

The question:
  • Is there a pop-up or add-on help system for Photoshop and/or Lightroom that any of you could recommend? (Something that does what Adobe should, but doesn’t, do. . .)



Re: [Digital BW] Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-09 by C D Tobie

> On Dec 9, 2016, at 7:21 AM, Myron Gochnauer goch@... [DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint] <DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint@yahoogroups.com> wrote:
> 
> The observations:
> The Adobe help functions for Photoshop and Lightroom are seriously inadequate for quick information and guidance.
> Help books for these programs have become an industry unto themselves. In attempting to be comprehensive most books make it difficult to answer specific questions that intermediate users, especially, face in the middle of a project.
> Good help for computer programs *is* possible.  Some are regrettably history - - the DOS word processor XyWrite’s early manuals were nearly perfect - - while others are limited to relatively small markets - - the text markup and formatting system LaTeX has a number of add-on help systems that are. . . well. . . helpful!

The days of DOS manuals are long gone, there have been so many changes in the industry since then that a comparison is pretty much meaningless. Back then, you got a fabric covered slipcover box, with sleeves for all the discs, and usually not one, but two big printed paperback books; certainly that was what Adobe sent for many years.

Help, at least on the Mac, is OS level help, and will get irrelevant results for other applications.

Some apps have excellent dedicated help as a separate item at the bottom of the Generic Help Menu list. Adobe has two items there, neither of which are Photoshop or Lightroom specific Help documents; let alone comprehensive User Guides; oddly, the one that takes you to the Adobe forums takes you to the plug-ins section.

On-line help and forums are a reality of modern life. The truth is that I seldom use that route for Adobe apps. For apps with much smaller audiences, a Google (or other) search brings up little or nothing, so you are obliged to use the help that comes with the app (and I find that such apps therefore tend to provide a traditional user guide); with Adobe apps there are many search hits, and I get my best results doing a general web search on my keywords, which may or may not take me to a related Adobe forum, or an expert’s website, or a video, etc. That’s the way to find answers, and if they don’t appear to be out there, then you have to leave a message on a forum (which may require signing up, and signing in) and wait, in hopes that someone answers, and that the answers are useful. 

Yes, Adobe apps are complex, require a new way of thinking, and a new vocabulary (or new definitions for an existing one), and are not intuitive to the new user, or sometimes to any user. Yes, a book or video series on learning to use them is recommended. And yes, it generally costs extra. Part of the cost of doing business. And yes, by the time you reach intermediate status, resources covering exactly what you are doing get much thinner on the ground.

Give thanks that you speak the most common language for use of these apps, or you would have yet another issue to complain about: that most Help, most books, and most tutorials are in English.

C. David Tobie
Senior Project Manager
Workflow & Color




Durst Phototechnik 
AG
Julius-Durst-Strasse 4
39042 Brixen, Italy
P.: +39 04 72 81 01 11
www.durst-group.com
cdtobie@...

skype: CDTobie

Re: [Digital BW] Re: Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-09 by Peter Marquis-Kyle

I share Myron's frustration with the inbuilt Lightroom help system -- 
and the same goes for the other Adobe programs.

My solution is to download the PDF reference documents from Adobe, and 
save them to my hard disk. Here is the one for Lightroom: 
https://helpx.adobe.com/pdf/lightroom_reference.pdf

It is not as convenient as a proper inbuilt help system, but it works. I 
also use carefully-crafted google searches to find answers to specific 
questions, as David Tobie mentioned.

-- 

Peter Marquis-Kyle
www.marquis-kyle.com.au

On 9/12/2016 10:21 PM, Myron Gochnauer goch@... 
[DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint] wrote:
Show quoted textHide quoted text
>   * Is there a pop-up or add-on help system for Photoshop and/or
>     Lightroom that any of you could recommend?  (Something that does
>     what Adobe should, but doesn\u2019t, do. . .)

Re: [Digital BW] Lightroom: 2 preset questions

2016-12-09 by Charles Babington

While I generally hate to watch an answer if I have the choice of reading it, I must say that if there’s a Julieanne Kost video on the Lightroom subject I’m wondering about I usually find a more than complete answer.  But not being able to get into those videos directly from a Lightroom screen is indeed frustrating.

Cheers,
Kip
Show quoted textHide quoted text
> On Dec 9, 2016, at 16:09, Peter Marquis-Kyle peter@... [DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint] <DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint@yahoogroups.com> wrote:
> 
> I share Myron's frustration with the inbuilt Lightroom help system -- 
> and the same goes for the other Adobe programs.
> 
> My solution is to download the PDF reference documents from Adobe, and 
> save them to my hard disk. Here is the one for Lightroom: 
> https://helpx.adobe.com/pdf/lightroom_reference.pdf <https://helpx.adobe.com/pdf/lightroom_reference.pdf>
> 
> It is not as convenient as a proper inbuilt help system, but it works. I 
> also use carefully-crafted google searches to find answers to specific 
> questions, as David Tobie mentioned.
> 
> -- 
> 
> Peter Marquis-Kyle
> www.marquis-kyle.com.au <http://www.marquis-kyle.com.au/>
>

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.