Question Regarding MIS VT-Ink/Roark Workflow
2001-08-23 by Howard Averbach
Question for users of the MIS Variable-Tone inksets and Paul Roark's adjustment curves: One of the steps outlined by Paul and others on this list is "convert the image from grayscale to RGB." Most of my work is restoration/copying of older photos. Although I am merely a neophyte, I have read several sources to the effect that even though the original image may be B&W, I should SCAN and then WORK within Photoshop in RGB. Prior to printing, the image should be turned into grayscale using the Photoshop Channel Mixer or selecting one of the R, G, B Channels, but not directly converting to grayscale. Among the reasons this all-RGB workflow is espoused is that it potentially allows for selection of the "cleanest" of the R, G, and B channels, finer adjustments, better contrast and three dimensionality, etc. If, in fact, working the B&W image in an RGB space allows for the aforesaid benefits, then it seems to contradict the workflow of using MIS VT inks and Paul Roark's curves because if one of the steps is "convert the image from grayscale to RGB," then the image must have been in the grayscale workspace and not RGB, or such conversion would not have been necessary. Given the names of well-known, experienced users who contribute to this list, not to mention Paul Roark himself, I must be missing something. Would one of the experienced MIS VT/Roark Curve users point out where in the workflow I am missing the boat. Thank you. Howard