Re: [Digital BW] Jon Cone on the "dyestuff" issue in PiezoTone Black
2002-06-16 by Jerry Olson
> Todd, I have seen the stepwedges of Piezotones black ink that were left in a fade tester for 100 hours. They faded quite badly. Very sepia. Do you think it possible for a wedge made with all the colors would prevent the black from fading? I've also seen bad fading with prints made with the epson 2000P and their "Archival Inks." So I wouldn't bet the farm on Anybody's claims any more. As I've mentioned countless times, I've never seen any fading with any inkset in the past 4 years, on any good paper, as long as the lighting conditions were low level, such as you'd find in the average home. The brighter the light, the worse they fade. No ink I have ever tested has gone much more than 3 months in direct sunlight without fading. I simply refuse to worry about fading any more. Jerry
Show quoted textHide quoted text
> > Ouch! Double ouch! > > Sorry to make you feel that I was disingenuous. I have not been. It is > complicated without giving away the technology (the farm). The only ink > position we stated that there is anything but pigment in, is the black ink > position. However, these materials have not been used as a dyestuff in any > other application that we know of, yet we are using them to act as a > dyestuff. Whether one argues the material is or is not a dyestuff is pretty= > > immaterial. We did something cool and unique and advanced the technology > with it. The inkset is real. It does not warm up like other inksets. It is > the most stable on the market. > > I have always been forthcoming in stating when there is dye in my inks. I > did that early on with the PiezographyBW inks. I am sorry to have stated to= > > you that there wasn't dyestuff in these. I can easily see why you would hav= > > e > felt that way. However, I am surprised to see your reaction (the use of the= > > word disingenuous). If you want disingenuous, go test quad inks whose > manufacturer and proponents state they are pure pigment and watch the > warm > fade. Warm fading is the dye components of a formula fading out fast while > the underlying carbon (which is brownish black) holds out. > > TO CLARIFY: > There is no doubt that something in addition to carbon black has been used > in the black ink position. The dMax of that ink position is too > extraordinary for there not to be. It may be dyestuff, it may not be > dyestuff. Or rather it may have not been dyestuff, but being used as > dyestuff it may be dyestuff now. > > In the other 3 gray positions, no materials other than pigment and colorles= > > s > ink-base have been used. > > The 3 gray positions are not dilutions of the black position, nor are they > dilutions of the darkest gray. Each has been formulated separately to creat= > > e > a great product. > > Any warm fading of the black position ink will be negligible because it is > printed in combination with the other gray position inks using the > PiezographyBW driver. While others prefer to use RGB workflow with the > EPSON > driver, we believe our driver is still superior to RGB workflows at this > point. The RGB workflows may or may not use more amount of black ink in the= > > dMax but there is still ample foundation of gray positions. It would be > surprising (positive) to find out that the PiezoTone inks are being used > with the Roark and Woolf curves instead of PiezographyBW software. > > No matter how you look at it, or dissect it, PiezoTones are the best quad > inks going and are very genuine! Beware imitations!!!!! :) > > I hope that this answers all your questions by the way. > > -------------------------------- > may your highlights be dotless > and your tonal scale smooth, > > Jon Cone > jon@c... > Piezography(tm) software and inks > http://www.piezography.com > > > Please visit the Group Homepage to check the Files, Bookmarks, Polls and other resources as they are often being updated. The page is at: > > http://groups.yahoo.com/group/DigitalBlackandWhiteThePrint > > Please follow these basic guidelines: > - Include your full name with your message. > - Include the address of your website, if you have one. > - As threads develop, trim off excess portions of earlier messages to keep them short. > - As the topic of a thread changes remember to change the subject header. > - Good manners are required at all time. No personal attacks or "flames." > - Complete your Yahoo profile. > - Before posting a question, search the message archives and the various resources on the homepage. > > > > Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/