Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Thread

Re: [Digital BW] SCSI or IDE for new Photoshop machine (OT)

Re: [Digital BW] SCSI or IDE for new Photoshop machine (OT)

2002-01-21 by Moreno Polloni

> I'm about to build a new PC for working on large images (500 MB) in
> Photoshop, and trying to decide between SCSI or IDE disks. I know this
> is fairly off-topic, but I respect the members of this group, and many
> of the images will be B&W, so be nice.
>
> The IDE setup could be a Western Digital 100G 7,200rpm (with 8MB buffer)
> as the system disk, plus a RAID-0 array of two 40G 7,200rpm drives for
> the scratch disk. Or, for about $400 net cost increase, I could use
> smaller but faster SCSI disks: a 73G 10,000rpm system disk and an 18G
> 15,000rpm scratch disk.
>
> I think the biggest advantage of the SCSI disks would be faster access
> times, but I don't know how much faster the SCSI machine would really be
> in practice, because I don't know what size data blocks Photoshop reads
> and writes to its scratch disk. Can anyone help?

I think you'll find the IDE drives fast enough. Not quite as fast as SCSI,
but very close. SCSI would show a much greater advantage if you were
building a server, but for a workstation it's value is questionable. In
addition to the extra expense, SCSI drives are also noisier and run hotter
(which in turn means more fans and more noise).

I'd suggest a small (30gb or so) drive to hold your operating system and
program files, and a large pair of striped drives for storage/work space. A
single or striped pair of 20gb files would be plenty for scatch space.

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.