Re: [Digital BW] SCSI or IDE for new Photoshop machine (OT)
2002-01-21 by Moreno Polloni
> I'm about to build a new PC for working on large images (500 MB) in > Photoshop, and trying to decide between SCSI or IDE disks. I know this > is fairly off-topic, but I respect the members of this group, and many > of the images will be B&W, so be nice. > > The IDE setup could be a Western Digital 100G 7,200rpm (with 8MB buffer) > as the system disk, plus a RAID-0 array of two 40G 7,200rpm drives for > the scratch disk. Or, for about $400 net cost increase, I could use > smaller but faster SCSI disks: a 73G 10,000rpm system disk and an 18G > 15,000rpm scratch disk. > > I think the biggest advantage of the SCSI disks would be faster access > times, but I don't know how much faster the SCSI machine would really be > in practice, because I don't know what size data blocks Photoshop reads > and writes to its scratch disk. Can anyone help? I think you'll find the IDE drives fast enough. Not quite as fast as SCSI, but very close. SCSI would show a much greater advantage if you were building a server, but for a workstation it's value is questionable. In addition to the extra expense, SCSI drives are also noisier and run hotter (which in turn means more fans and more noise). I'd suggest a small (30gb or so) drive to hold your operating system and program files, and a large pair of striped drives for storage/work space. A single or striped pair of 20gb files would be plenty for scatch space.