Thanks for the responses guys. (And yes, sarcasm = off) Appreciate the diplomacy demonstrated, and Steve's response was great, although doesn't really clarify the legal stance. Yes American synth manuals are excellent and informationally valuable. I just can't help feeling that, once support evaporates for a product, that ownership of copyright of the instructions for that product which you may need to use that product, also evaporates. Of course it's great that copies of these instructions are accumulated and sold - and I'm not necessarily taking the cyber hippy stance of "information is free" etc. I am interested in the true legalities of 80s/90s synth doco (including service documentation - there seems to be more and more of it freely available on the Internet), but one fact which was not really obvious, and that puts a peculiar slant on the discussion, is that the owner of this mailgroup has a commercial interest in their distribution of the documentation referred to - this kinda makes the group an advertising corridor of sorts. While it's hard not to take indifference to the implied standover comment (thread subject), and I didn't really think it was in the spirit of the public mailing list, I respect the fact that it is your (route66's) list and I certainly respect any entity that provides speciality support to a synth community. Apologies for the rudeness, and happy synthesizing. regards, Mike --- In Ensoniq-VFX-SD@yahoogroups.com, mishon66@a... wrote: > Mike and Frank > > It's to bad you are so easily dissuaded, I would hate to have to talk you out of shooting yourself in the foot. But if you do indeed find your PDF manual or bad Xerox copy on Ebay or some private web page good for you...but it wont happen here on this group. > > As far as stepping on toes and shameless plugs. > I have encouraged and welcomed every member and company here to share and advertise any item, upgrade, sound set or information that he or she has created. That is more than I can say for MOST of the web groups out there. If you want to market PDF manuals Great! then go and get a license to do so but don't come on this group slamming company's that are offering a service and supporting this user community. > > Richard at Route 66
Message
Re: Posting VFX manual bad idea
2003-09-17 by rf_erf
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.