Yahoo Groups archive

QTR-Quadtone RIP

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:12 UTC

Message

Re: QIDF versus ICC

2016-07-28 by brian_downunda@...

Quite a lot has been written in response, some of it quite advanced, and I don't want to add too much more. I have a lot of sympathy for the views in Eugene's initial post. When people coming to QTR read of QTR curves being referred to as profiles they get understandably confused, a point I've made before. That said, you seem to have a good understanding. I agree with you and Richard that the media type setting in the Epson driver seems to be the closest analogy, except that you can't add new ones or adjust the existing ones as you can in QTR.

The issue of whether to use an ICC - produced by the Create ICC (RGB) droplet - just for soft-proofing or to convert to it for printing has been a vexed issue. In my view, a lot of it has to do with what style of print you want and perhaps what sort of images you print. Clearly Richard and I and in a different camp to Paul.

There was a heated debate with Jon Cone some (seven) years ago on another Yahoo forum. Partly in light of that exchange, I wrote a post outlining some of the issues for new users, esp those coming from a colour workflow:
http://www.cyberhalides.com/piezography-printing/the-piezography-heretic-to-convert-or-not-to-convert/


I don't pretend that this is a sophisticated analysis, since it's aimed at new users with less technical knowledge that you seem to have, but you may find it helpful all the same. It was written in the context of Piezography, but it applies to any B&W inkset including OEM-K3. Bear in mind that it's also a little tongue-in-cheek.


I know that Richard loves his Macs, but both OS X and Windows have their advantages and disadvantages. They both work. Use what you know are are most comfortable. Print Tool is a great program, but QTRGui is quite useable, esp the curve creator. In either case, you can't print direct from PS anymore, so I don't see a huge difference in the workflows, and I have tried the OS X one. I may have switched to OS X some years ago for printing, but the combined antics of Apple and Adobe to break things, accidentally or intentionally, removed most of the potential advantages for me.


---In QuadtoneRIP@yahoogroups.com, <info@...> wrote :

My intuition tells me that these curves are more like media type settings since they control ink levels. The profile would be the ICC profile being created using the Eye one and the Create ICC RGB droplet. If my intuition is correct than the curves (media types) and profiles should be working in tandem.

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.