Re: imaging/ depth of field
2005-05-05 by darkstr1746@comcast.net
thanks for the early morning tutorial. I need information like that to bring me up to speed. It's not easy being lost back in the early seventies..... hell, sixties. I especially like the take on modern syth "stereo" recordings. I have been trying to get away from that by just recording one channel and doing the external processing from that one track.
But with the Serge, i have nothing to worry about right from the off. Everything is mono tracks because each sound i create is discreet. A concept i adhered to while recording Paleozoic Twilight. So when i'm doing "modular music", imaging becomes important to me. Depth of field is also important.Large "sweet spot" is probably farther on down the list.
So now that I'v received more information than i know what to do with regarding power amps. I guess i should pose the obvious question of which speakers do people think do the best job of imaging while retaining good depth of field.?? Or does the question even have any significance because of the fact that most home studios are in small bedrooms or basements where physical conditions render such considerations moot?
What happens in the reviewers studio or in the "studio/listening" room at the local GC won't mean a thing when the above conditions are applied. This may be pushing the OT fringe for the AH list. If so, please reply to me personaly. Otherwise Mark may have to put down his morning brew and give me a whack. : )
kind regards
john duval
kind regars
john duval
-------------- Original message --------------
John "I'm selling my Serge... no, really, I MEAN it this time" Duval wrote:
John "I'm selling my Serge... no, really, I MEAN it this time" Duval wrote:
Show quoted textHide quoted text
>Imaging is more an ability to close one's eyes, listen, then point
> What is imaging?? Is that what us oldtimers used to call
>"spread"or "depth of field"???
and say, "The guitarist was standing THERE." It's not so much the
width or depth of the soundstage... those can be faked pretty easily
in DSP... but its detail as perceived by the ear. I have heard
monitors with incredible depth of field that have lousy imaging, and
I've heard monitors with amazing imaging that have good but not
exceptional depth of field. Neither has anything strictly to do with
another useful concept, which is dispersion, a.k.a. how wide the
sweet spot is. With really good imaging, you don't just have a vague
left-right-phantom center, but a very realistic and involving
sensation of musical sources in a stereo listening environment, with
all the time and amplitude cues that your ears need to reconstruct
the world around you.
That having been said, I should note that imaging is most important
for listening to jazz or classical music, since for most modern synth
music, imaging is meaningless, because no one understands how to use
synths in mono any more. Almost every synth on the market has stereo
outputs, where a dry sound that may or may not have a particular pan
position is slathered with full-on stereo reverb and chorusing. A
"mix" is no longer a virtual stage with one synth over here and
another synth over there, but a sort of sonic baklavah of layered
full-width stereo images on top of one another, having nothing in
common and all muscling for the same domination of the soundstage.
When something dynamic *does* get put into the stereo panorama, it's
likely to be an LFO-driven autopan that makes the dry sound swirl
sickeningly within the reverb, like a spoon futilely trying to stir
congealed gravy.
This is where engineers get the expression, "If everything's in
stereo, nothing's in stereo."
mike
--
"The problem with this is that you are no longer dealing with true
silence. You are dealing with 'replicated' silence. The best silence
is analogue." (d. morley)
====================================================================
Atomic City* Box 17083 Boulder CO 80308-0083 * metlay@...
mindSpiral: space music with a smile! * http://www.mindspiral.com
SynthSights! "it's not about the gear"
-- www.synthsights.net