I¹m sure that as soon as I ask this I¹ll figure out that I¹m overlooking something simple, but I¹m puzzled right now. I¹m hoping that someone can spend the considerable effort to try to figure out what¹s going wrong here, or what I¹m misunderstanding. I¹ve narrowed this down to the interaction of 2 tracks. Basically the issue is that somehow the p3 is sending controller #24, which is modulating the filter envelope of my mfb synth 2, which I definitely don¹t want at the moment. But I don¹t see that I¹m telling the p3 to send this controller. I¹m also perhaps not understanding how the push aux to track n works.....as explained below. Currently, only track 1 and track 6 are activated. When track 1 is mute, track 6 (which sends the controllers) does NOT send controller #24 and sends only controllers #22 and #29, which is to be expected. Track 6 has: Aux 1: push. Only 1 step selected, which is pushing aux b to track 1. So, there is no controller explicitly sent on this aux event. Aux 2: rep*n by length. Only the same step as above is selected. Again no controller. Aux 3: cc#29 Aux 4: cc#22 Track 1 has: Aux 1: Grab all steps are grabbing velocity from another track Aux 2: xpose by trak n Aux 3 and 4: nothing set The midi monitor program I¹m running is showing that the controller #24 is coming from the p3 port on my midi timepiece av. Again when port 1 is muted, Now this is interesting I just edited things so that track one sends on channel 2 (track 6 is sending on channel 1). Sometimes the controller events are being sent on channel 2 and sometimes they are being sent on channel 1. So, it kind of looks like the push event is actually pushing aux b, c, and d, to track 1. This can¹t be the way the push event works?! (if so, why not have a push all subsequent aux events choice instead? And I¹m still confused as to where controller 24 is coming from. 20:12:24.439 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 22 87 20:12:24.554 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 82 20:12:24.555 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:24.671 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 23 20:12:24.672 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 19 20:12:24.789 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:24.906 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 53 20:12:24.906 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 107 20:12:25.023 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 102 20:12:25.024 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.140 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 14 20:12:25.141 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.257 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 1 20:12:25.258 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.374 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 108 20:12:25.375 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.492 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 31 20:12:25.493 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 58 20:12:25.609 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 113 20:12:25.610 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.726 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 20 20:12:25.843 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 13 20:12:25.844 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:25.961 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:26.077 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 85 20:12:26.078 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:26.194 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 24 52 20:12:26.196 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 29 7 20:12:26.196 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 22 87 20:12:26.312 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 82 20:12:26.313 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:26.429 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 23 20:12:26.430 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 19 20:12:26.546 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:26.664 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 53 20:12:26.664 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 107 20:12:26.781 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 102 20:12:26.782 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:26.898 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 14 20:12:26.899 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.015 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 1 20:12:27.016 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.133 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 108 20:12:27.133 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.250 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 31 20:12:27.251 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 58 20:12:27.367 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 113 20:12:27.368 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.484 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 20 20:12:27.601 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 13 20:12:27.602 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.718 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.836 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 85 20:12:27.836 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:27.952 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 24 52 20:12:27.954 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 29 7 20:12:27.954 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 2 Controller 22 87 20:12:28.070 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 82 20:12:28.071 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:28.187 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 23 20:12:28.188 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 19 20:12:28.305 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:28.422 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 53 20:12:28.422 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 107 20:12:28.539 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 102 20:12:28.540 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:28.656 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 14 20:12:28.657 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 22 13 20:12:28.773 From MIDI Timepiece AV Port 7 Control 1 Controller 29 1 [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Message
p3 v4 controller weirdness
2007-06-21 by Gene Schwartz
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.