Yahoo Groups archive

Datacolor User to User Support Group.

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:18 UTC

Thread

Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-04 by sergecashman

I just noticed that the update for Spyder2Express software changes the
only available target for LCD to 6500K.

Why would you do that? Native white point target for LCDs was
considered to be one of the advantages of Spyder2Express over the i1 LT.

If there was some pressure on Colorvision (from whoever was
complaining) to include 6500K and D65 you could make all of them
available. It wouldn't cost you anything and make your product more
competitive.

Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-04 by Keith Cooper

--- In colorvision_group@yahoogroups.com, "sergecashman" <sergecashman@...> wrote:
>
> I just noticed that the update for Spyder2Express software changes the
> only available target for LCD to 6500K.

I hadn't spotted that one - thanks

Given I know several people who specifically went for the S2e because of the
'native' setting I'd initially be minded to warn people not to upgrade.

Certainly with my Apple 23" monitor I've found that calibrators with a 'native'
setting tend to give me a better greyscale.

So I'd ask (if it's correct - I have not tested things) why 6500K? it's not like most
people using the S2e are going to be wanting precise settings for proofing...  Is
this related to the 'native' performance of cheap(er) lcd screens (which make up
the bulk of the market) or perhaps trying to make a room full of monitors look
a bit more alike? --or, putting tinfoil conspiracy hat on-- has 'marketing' been
at work ;-)

Keith Cooper
http://www.northlight-images.co.uk

Re: [colorvision_group] Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-04 by CDTobie@aol.com


In a message dated 6/3/06 11:49:05 PM, sergecashman@... writes:


I just noticed that the update for Spyder2Express software changes the
only available target for LCD to 6500K.

Why would you do that? Native white point target for LCDs was
considered to be one of the advantages of Spyder2Express over the i1 LT.


Not by most reviewers... it was the other way around, and popular demand was for 6500, not native, as a standard.

If there was some pressure on Colorvision (from whoever was
complaining) to include 6500K and D65 you could make all of them
available. It wouldn't cost you anything and make your product more
competitive.

Thats debatable; putting all of Spyder2PRO's features into Spyder2express wouldn't "cost" anything, except for the loss of all Spyder2 and Spyder2PRO sales. But more to the point: the idea of Spyder2express is that its a no settings, automatic process. Asking users to choose whitepoints, when many don't know what a whitepoint is, or what the choices mean, is not ideal for an entry level product. This type of criticism tends to come from advanced users, not the level of user that Spyder2express is designed for.

C. David Tobie
Product Technology Manager
ColorVision Business Division
DataColor Inc.
CDTobie@...
www.colorvision.com


Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by sergecashman

Well, now you'll have all sorts of "I calibrated my monitor now it's
too blue" complaints. You don't have to put all Pro features in - just
the ones that make sense. Native wp made a lot of sense for the
majority of users even if they don't know it. If 6500K is in such
demand make it an "advanced user"  option. 

You'll sell tons of Expresses as long as reviews frome people like
Keeth Cooper are good. Nothing will replace the Pro features like
validation, info, colorimeter information for advanced users - but
there will always be few of those.

Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by sergecashman

And, umm, I've had a couple of really inaccurate profiles created by
S2E. I mean way off. Most of them are OK though. I've seen some
similar posts on messageboards. And there's no way to tell if the
profile is correct. Maybe some non-explicit validation (at least for
white point) can be included in the software a well.

Re: [colorvision_group] Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by CDTobie@aol.com


In a message dated 6/4/06 9:07:33 PM, sergecashman@... writes:


Well, now you'll have all sorts of "I calibrated my monitor now it's
too blue" complaints. You don't have to put all Pro features in - just
the ones that make sense. Native wp made a lot of sense for the
majority of users even if they don't know it. If 6500K is in such
demand make it an "advanced user" option.


Actually, I had lots of complaints from Europe (where the preceeding program, ColorPLUS, was available for both Windows and Mac, instead of just for Windows, as in North America) about Mac monitors being too blue, too yellow, and impossible to balance to one another at Native Whitepoint. 6500k allows a consistant setting. The real question is whether LCDs are good enough these days to handle white point compensation or not, as the place where it used to cause problems was with inferior screens.

You'll sell tons of Expresses as long as reviews frome people like
Keeth Cooper are good.


Actually, reviews were going to suffer if we didn't offer the "magic" of adjusting your whitepoint, as head to head comparisons with Huey would show that Huey "did something" that we didn't do.

Nothing will replace the Pro features like
validation, info, colorimeter information for advanced users - but
there will always be few of those.

It was inevitable that whichever way we designed express, it would garner some complaints, and that changing it after release would garner even more, but the decision was that it was important enough to take that hit and make that change, even though there would be complaints.

By the way, upgrading to Spyder2 will get you native whitepoint, along with other adjustable settings for whitepoint and gamma. Those who don't need the PRO features, but want these controls, can get them for the price difference between express and Spyder2.

C. David Tobie
Product Technology Manager
ColorVision Business Unit
Datacolor Inc.
CDTobie@...

www.colorvision.com

Re: [colorvision_group] Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by CDTobie@aol.com


In a message dated 6/4/06 9:16:19 PM, sergecashman@... writes:


And, umm, I've had a couple of really inaccurate profiles created by
S2E. I mean way off. Most of them are OK though. I've seen some
similar posts on messageboards. And there's no way to tell if the
profile is correct. Maybe some non-explicit validation (at least for
white point) can be included in the software a well.


Spyder2express is a subset of Spyder2 and Spyder2PRO. Other than limiting the available features the color functions are identical. If you got a wacky result with express, you would have gotten that same result with PRO, at the default settings. If you continue to get such results, please contact customerservice@..., so that they can get a report from you on the issue.

C. David Tobie
Product Technology Manager
ColorVision Business Unit
Datacolor Inc.
CDTobie@...

www.colorvision.com

Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by Tom

> Spyder2express is a subset of Spyder2 and Spyder2PRO. Other than
limiting the 
> available features the color functions are identical. If you got a
wacky 
> result with express, you would have gotten that same result with
PRO, at the 
> default settings. If you continue to get such results, please contact 
> customerservice@..., so that they can get a report from you on the
issue.
> 
> C. David Tobie
> Product Technology Manager
> ColorVision Business Unit
> Datacolor Inc.
> CDTobie@...
> www.colorvision.com
>

If you ever get your Spyder2 damp be forewarned.  There is a sad story
attached to this point.  My first Spyder2 went back and forth with me
in my bag to work.  (I sneak out at lunch to take photos in Downtown
DC).  Unfortunately one day a rather badly behaved bottle of soda
decided to let loose inside my bag.  A puddle of carbonated beverage
sloshed around at the bottom of my bag considerably raising the
humidity inside.  The Spyder2 behaved (ahem) erraticly after that.  

On further examination ... after purchasing another replacement ... I
noticed that there is a small filter element inside the now wacked
unit.  The tiny magenta filter on this unit sucks up water like a
magnet!  Comparing the behavior of the two units it was clear that the
first colorimiter had been damaged by the extreme humidity.

Moral of the story?  Don't mix colorimiters and fizzy drinks ... even
without direct contact, extreme humidity will damage your equipment. 
Second ... if you do trash one colorimeter you can get a cheaper unit
and just use the colorimeter with your old software ;-)  My
colorimeter now lives in a tight dry heavy duty ziplock bag with one
of those silica gel packs to make sure its cool dry and comfy.

Best of luck and good shooting!

Tom

Re: [colorvision_group] Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by CDTobie@aol.com


In a message dated 6/5/06 10:18:00 AM, ttrostel@... writes:


If you ever get your Spyder2 damp be forewarned.


Wratten filters are organic, and not to be saturated; thats a given, in any brand of monitor calibrator. The Huey just makes this easier by being in the shape of a swizzle stick...

C. David Tobie
Product Technology Manager
ColorVision Business Unit
Datacolor Inc.
CDTobie@...

www.colorvision.com

Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by Tom

> The Huey just makes this easier by being in the 
> shape of a swizzle stick...

Pfft ... you should hear what happened to my iPod mini.  Lets just say
it passed "extreme shock testing".

Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by sergecashman

OK, let me try one more time:

You alredy offer two white point options for Express. Unfortunately to
change the target a user would have to reinstall the software. That
makes Colorvision look like a bunch of... you know...  people who
don't care much about customer experience.

Re: [colorvision_group] Re: Spyder2Express - 6500K for LCDs?

2006-06-05 by CDTobie@aol.com


In a message dated 6/5/06 2:37:21 PM, sergecashman@... writes:


OK, let me try one more time:

You alredy offer two white point options for Express.


No: we offer one, its a single setting application, no calibration choices involved.

Unfortunately to
change the target a user would have to reinstall the software.


Most users won't have both versions of the software, and only geeks would change between them for whitepoint definition. Geeks should be using a more advanced software, such as Spyder2, or Spyder2PRO, both of this offer native, 6500k, and other whitepoints. (I'm a geek, and thats certainly what I do. )

That
makes Colorvision look like a bunch of... you know... people who
don't care much about customer experience.

No, it makes ColorVision look like a company that has gone out of their way to best meet customer needs, even though we knew that it would cause some grumbling... such as this thread.

C. David Tobie
Product Technology Manager
ColorVision Business Unit
Datacolor Inc.
CDTobie@...

www.colorvision.com

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.