It is a natural trait of any technician to be able to beat their subject to death, myself included, but I cannot emphasize enough the role of friction and geometry in piano actions that determines the quality of playback you get on a Disklavier. It was a good point brought up that many of these MIDI files are created on electronic keyboards and that their velocities do not always accurately reproduce on the DKV. This is because real pianos have real working mechanical parts that produce the sound. Both the key and hammer sensors on a DKV are for recording purposes only; not playback. Playback-only models do not even have these sensors. The measurements generated from these sensors create a Piano Tables Condition that record the speed (velocity)of both the hammer and key movement when recording. There is no way these numbers can reflect actual volume as that is generated by the hammer hitting the string. That is why the PPP value adjustment needs to be set on each piano for each key. The factory defaults only put the piano in the ballpark, not the concert hall. The volume generated on a piano, whether it is activated by playing the keys or the keys being pushed up from the rear by a firing solenoid, comes solely from the mechanical force of the hammer hitting the string. A lot goes into this! One of the nice things about regulating a piano action with an electronic player installed on it is that you can generate a constant blow and see how this is affected by varying amounts of friction in the piano action. The areas most affected by friction are the whippen cushion felts (where the brass capstan screw on the back of the key contacts the piano action), and the leather knuckles on a grand piano or the leather on the hammer butts on an upright. You can feel this friction when you try to play the piano softly. It's amazing what a very light application of microfine teflon powder on these areas will do to make the piano play with more control. The other important factor in piano volume is the density of the felt hammers that hit the strings. This is a science all by itself, and most piano technicians spend their entire careers learning and practicing the techniques of tone regulation. Some pianos have hammers that are so hard they create a very loud tone on the softest of blows. THese pianos need a lot of "voicing" to be able to play softly. In conclusion, the volume of the Disklavier is controlled not only by the MIDI value of the velocity in the software, but by the physical, mechanical parts of the piano action generating the sound as well. It is a complex adjustment of the geometry and friction of the piano action, the density of the piano hammer, and the re-computing of the DKV Tables in Maintenance Mode. You can't get the best results by emphasizing only one part of the process! Those pianos that get tuning only will eventually have their dynamic range compromised. Carol Beigel _________________________________________________________________ Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com
Message
The Mechanics of Volume
2001-06-16 by Carol Beigel
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.