Yahoo Groups archive

The Logic Off Topic list

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:27 UTC

Thread

Re; Guitarists

Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by greydug

You sad f***ers!
You all sound like fifty-year-old teenagers.
To copy someone note for note is the reason why the music business is full of TRIBUTE bands.
Write your own songs and play your own guitar parts - if they're good enough, people will pay money to hear you play.
Regards
Graeme Douglas


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by Hendrik Jan Veenstra

Thoughts from the mind of greydug, 26-06-2001:

>You sad f***ers!
>You all sound like fifty-year-old teenagers.
>To copy someone note for note is the reason why the music business 
>is full of TRIBUTE bands.
>Write your own songs and play your own guitar parts - if they're 
>good enough, people will pay money to hear you play.

Wow... attitude problem alert...

-- 
     Hendrik Jan Veenstra
     email: mailto:h@...
     www:   http://www.ision.nl/users/h/index.html

Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by Dennis Gunn

At 9:52 AM +0100 6/26/01, greydug wrote:
>You sad f***ers!
>You all sound like fifty-year-old teenagers.
>To copy someone note for note is the reason why the music business 
>is full of TRIBUTE bands.
>Write your own songs and play your own guitar parts - if they're 
>good enough, people will pay money to hear you play.
>Regards
>Graeme Douglas

Well Graeme I can't speak for these other guys but personally I have 
written hundreds of songs.  And played on several albums by my own 
bands, dozens of albums by other people, as well as movie and TV 
sound tracks and TV commercials.

I don't find learning other people's songs and guitar parts demeaning 
at all.   I find it educational.

But I suppose you have probably done much better and know much better 
than any of us "sad f***er's"  how to move ahead in the biz so do 
please share some of your vast experience and wisdom.
-- 


                                 Dennis Gunn
                                 Mightyjohn@...

                  check out  MIGHTY JOHN HENRY's album "hot air head"
                                                    info at
                        http://www.twics.com/~mightyjo/home.html

Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by yoonchi@chello.nl

--- In logic-ot@y..., Hendrik Jan Veenstra <h@k...> wrote:
> Thoughts from the mind of greydug, 26-06-2001:
> 
> >You sad f***ers!
> >You all sound like fifty-year-old teenagers.
> >To copy someone note for note is the reason why the music business 
> >is full of TRIBUTE bands.
> >Write your own songs and play your own guitar parts - if they're 
> >good enough, people will pay money to hear you play.
> 
> Wow... attitude problem alert...

LOL. You MoFos need to grow-up, old farts, ;-).
Seriously, he needs to mature, ;-).
It's not copying notes. It's finding the elegance of how the notes were played

Talking about old fart music: I was listening to an old album of that little midget from Meneapolis, Prince. There is a keyboard riff in the song "Head"(hmm, talking about teenagers) on the album "Dirty Mind". I  said to myself: "Why wouldn't I think of such a riff when playing keys?" It's very easy and very effective to keep the funkyness going in that song. Without that riff, the song is completly boring

Words from an old teenager,
Yoonchi.

SV: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by Per Boysen

Hey "you sad f***ers" didn anyone mention David Gilmour? I deleted a bunch of this thread, so excuse me if he has already been up here :)  Now I'm sitting here learning the guitar parts of old Pink Floyd songs for a cover band party and it just hit me how cool this musician is! 

Per Boysen / between teenager and fifty ;)  


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

RE: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by Phil Angus

From: Per Boysen [mailto:per@...] said:

Hey "you sad f***ers" didn anyone mention David Gilmour?

You obviously totally ignore my postings then as I never talk guitarists
without mentioning Dave Gilmour.

By the way, in my list of great solos I said Steve Howe - Sound Chaser from
Relayer. I actually meant the track Awaken from Going For The One. The way
he just controls the feedback at the right point, and the notes he plays.
Fan bloody tastic.

And to the sad f**ck**, well it looks like you got the response you wanted.
What's up, did you get ignored as a child?!

SV: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-26 by Per Boysen

-----Ursprungligt meddelande-----
  Från: Phil Angus [mailto:phil.angus@...]
Show quoted textHide quoted text
  From: Per Boysen [mailto:per@...] said:

  Hey "you sad f***ers" didn anyone mention David Gilmour?

  You obviously totally ignore my postings then as I never talk guitarists
  without mentioning Dave Gilmour. 

  Ouch! I shouln't have deleted this thread earlier today... sorry.

   
   By the way, in my list of great solos I said Steve Howe - Sound Chaser from
  Relayer.  

  The Telecaster.  ´Such an ugly piece of wood - such a cocky sound. Relayer.

  PEr


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-27 by cas@s.netic.de

Since we're talking the most inaccurately covered song's in 
music history, I nominate 'Kiss' from Prince. I've never been in or 
seen a band that played this song properly. Not talking about the 
progression (it's essentially a blues), but the voicing of the 
chords. 

Not too old for the new; Not too young for the old,

Charles Simmons
Stuttgart, Germany

Yoonchi wrote:
> 
> Talking about old fart music: I was listening to an old album of 
that little midget from Meneapolis, Prince. There is a keyboard riff 
in the song "Head"(hmm, talking about teenagers) on the album 
"Dirty Mind". I  said to myself: "Why wouldn't I think of such a riff 
when playing keys?" It's very easy and very effective to keep the 
funkyness going in that song. Without that riff, the song is 
completly boring
Show quoted textHide quoted text
> 
> Words from an old teenager,
> Yoonchi.

Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-27 by Hendrik Jan Veenstra

Thoughts from the mind of yoonchi@..., 26-06-2001:

>Talking about old fart music: I was listening to an old album of 
>that little midget from Meneapolis, Prince.

If you call any album from Prince "old", then you're surely too young :-).

"Old" is calling King Crimson's "Beat" and "Discipline" the "new King 
Crimson" (as opposed to KC from 'Red' and such) -- as I caught myself 
doing this week.

-- 
     Hendrik Jan Veenstra
     email: mailto:h@...
     www:   http://www.ision.nl/users/h/index.html

Re: Re: [L-OT] Re; Guitarists

2001-06-27 by GAmoore@aol.com

Since when is a song about blow jobs "boring"? Maybe musically, but you 
need to read the lyrics too. 
Show quoted textHide quoted text
>"Head"(hmm, talking about teenagers) on the album 
>"Dirty Mind". I  said to myself: "Why wouldn't I think of such a riff 
>when playing keys?" It's very easy and very effective to keep the 
>funkyness going in that song. Without that riff, the song is 
>completly boring

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.