Yahoo Groups archive

MOTM

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:35 UTC

Message

Re: [motm] Sockets vs. soldering ICs directly to PCB?

2001-03-09 by J. Larry Hendry

> ----- Original Message -----
> From: John Blacet <blacet@...>
> I see the same *stuff* every time someone
> mentions "sockets". How much of it is true
> and how much of it just *stuff* that goes on and on?
---
Good question.
---
> We use sockets because it improves the reliability
> of our modules.  Modern day sockets are well made
> and reliable, even the cheaper variety.
---
No doubt, parts are better than they used to be.
---
> Using sockets lowers the amount of time that ICs are
> exposed to static prone conditions. This is especially
> true with kit builders, who may not have the sophisticated
> anti static facilities of industry.
---
I never thougth about that aspect.  But, I have never damaged
a chip this way using "reasonable" precautions.
---
> .... a non-socketed IC is a no brainer for anyone who
> has had to remove a bad IC from a DS board; it takes
> about 20 times as long and runs the risk of damaging
>  the PCB itself.
---
Been there, done that. Ouch!
---
> Our warranty is essentially void if the kit builder does not
> use the sockets provided. At the least, the usually very
> nominal repair charge runs the risk of *tripling* in the case
> of an IC failure.
---
Ouch.  I didn't know that.  That in itself I suppose is reason enough
to use all the sockets when I build my two Time Machines.   But,
it does leave me with one more question.

I did purchase some of those reasonably-nice, machined-socket, gold-contact
IC sockets (about 40 cents, I think) for the purpose of prototyping.  I must
certainly agree with Crow that sockets are essential for this work.  So, I
was
toying with the idea of using them when I did socket stuff on my Blacet
modules.
However......
---
> I cannot point to a single incident of a socket problem in the history
> of Blacet Research.
---
That's a lot of history to argue with.  So, I wonder....  I would assume
that you
mention of warranty would not care which IC socket was used.

Thanks for your comments John.

Larry Hendry

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.