Yahoo Groups archive

MOTM

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:35 UTC

Message

Re: CDW Lifespan

2002-04-08 by mmarsh100

It was handling.  In my truck, on the floor-boards after surf-
fishing.  That sort of thing.  I noticed that the media flaked off of 
someone else's CD-R that I bought, also mis-handled...

Mike

--- In motm@y..., "coyoteous" <satori@t...> wrote:
> The problem is probably marginal media, a wonky burner, 
> handling, storage conditions or labeling:
> 
> 1) It's almost impossible to tell the "good" media from the "bad" 
> these days without a several thousand dollar error analyzer (best 
> if it also has an RF analog output). In most cases cost of the 
> media is not an indicator of quality. Quality can very within a 
> single batch.
> 
> 2) Obviously, if the disc is failing somewhere down the road from 
> the burn, it's probably not the burner - but not always. But again, 
> specialized test equipment is required. These days, it is a fallacy 
> that you will get a better burn at a lower speed - you might or you 
> might not. Burn disc-at-once (DAO), if possible. I highly 
> recommend Plextor drives.
> 
> 3) Handing: here's one you can do something about. Avoid 
> handling the "read" side, though the other side is actually the 
> most mechanically fragile of the two. Use the the hole and the 
> edges. Any CD or DVD should always be "in" or on its way to 
> being "in" something (case, sleeve, tray, caddy). Avoid slot 
> loaders (not always possible).
> 
> 4) Storage: extended UV exposure will kill a CD-R. Avoid soft 
> plastic sleeves and cases (clamshells). Gases from these will 
> damage the top side of any CD/DVD over time. They have other 
> problems, too. The verdict is still out on the sort of "in between 
> hard and soft" DVD boxes, I avoid them for CD-R or DVD-R. Use 
> Tyvek or acid-free paper sleeves or any of a number of "real" 
> hard plastic Jewel  boxes.
> 
> 5) Never* use anything but a water soluble marker to write on a 
> CD, a Sanford Sharpie will  absolutely cause the disc to fail 
> somewhere down the road. I use them when I want something 
> to "time bomb." You are writing on three micro thin layers of 
stuff, 
> the bottom one is your data. Paper "stomper" labels have 
> problems in CD-ROM drives and slot loaders for obvious 
> reasons. Inkjet, thermal print and silkscreen are good if done 
> properly.
> 
> * Sharpie on the clear inner ring seems to be okay - not much 
> room to write anything, though (date, project #, etc.)
> 
> I will analyze CDs for MOTM ;-)
> 
> Barry
> 
> 
> --- In motm@y..., "mmarsh100" <mmarsh@s...> wrote:
> > Hello All -
> > 
> > For the veritable *mountain* of folks that ordered my CD, I've 
> run 
> > into some troble with the CDW's longevitiy.  I haven't treated 
> them 
> > at all well, but 1 year and then skips is a problem.
> > 
> > If you have my CD and actually want to listen to it in future, 
> please 
> > take abnormal care with it!  If it's already trashed, then send 
me 
> 3 
> > bucks (for postage) via PayPal and I'll send you a new one.  If 
it 
> > gets trashed in future, the deal still holds.
> > 
> > One day when I'm rich and famous, I'll have it pressed...
> > 
> > Mike, currently working on "Son of Absolute Truth"

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.