Yahoo Groups archive

MOTM

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:35 UTC

Thread

Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-27 by J. Larry Hendry

> ----- Original Message -----
> From: jwbarlow@...
> What is this "conductive mesh" that you mention?

It is a very fine weeve of copper wire.  That is the best way I know to
describe it.  It is very thin and flexible, like wide Christmas ribbon.  It
has adhesive on one side.  Apparently a surplus product once used by NASA.

> I'd like to see this.

I am in central Indiana, just north of Indianapolis about 15
 miles. :)  Come on over and take a look.... <g>
Or, you can look at the photo I just uploaded:
http://www.wiseguysynth.com/larry/misc/mesh.jpg
misc-mesh. <nyck nyck>

> What is the maximum length of the mesh?

I got it in 25 foot rolls, 1" wide.  I got enough to make a sh*t load of 2
or 3 foot ribbons.

> How are you making the resistive element?

I was thinking about nichrome wire.  The cool thing about that is you could
have 2 or 3 wires in parallel so you could get more than one CV from the
ribbon.  I have several different protos drawn up with a switchable point in
the middle so you could have a split point that could be switched on or off.
The configurations are endless.  But, it has to be simple for me to make it
work.  No uP.  No start point when you first touch it. No assignable split
points.  Get the KW MIDI ribbon thing for all that BS.  But, it could have
all the cool features you could implement in the analog world.  Gate OUT of
course. Maybe the 2nd or 3rd wire could be used to trigger another CV on
which could be used like an aftertouch or an actual trigger since the actual
gate will stay high as long as the ribbon is depressed. Since the ribbon is
1" wide you could slide along the lower half for CV and maybe hit
re-triggers with your other finger at the top as you move along.

> I remember Moe giving us (me) a rather good
> description of the mechanics of his old Moog ribbon.
> As I recall, the > ribbon was suspended above
> the resistive strip by a spring mechanism.

Yes, that is really the hard part. My latest idea is to use thin foam (like
you see used to wrap things for protection).The nichrome wire would sit in
slots in the foam and the mesh is adhesive on top of that.  Now, look at me
giving away all my secrets.

The electronics would be the easy part.  However, some challenges are there
because even fine Nichrome wire may only have 50-100 ohms in a 3 foot piece.

My basic thought was this, a nice walnut wood base about 3 inches wide and 2
to 3 foot long.  Most if not all the controls for range, split, reversing,
etc, would be in a module that the ribbon would plug into.  Putting the
controls are the ribbon end means you have a lot larger connecting cable.

> Glad you're still thinking of it!

Yes, it is on the "to do" list.  However, Stooge panels, flat rails, end
caps, and a variety of other things have kept me from getting to much of the
"to-do" list.  I plan to change that after I get my cabinets built and my
synth module building caught up.  Doing the Blacet Miniwave and Time Machine
conversions and the complete documentation of that process took a lot of
time and put me behind.  Plus I have been scanning lots of documentation and
writing disk drive replacement instructions for my beloved Korg DSS-1 and
DSM-1 sampling synths.  And, soon it will be Harley riding weather.  We got
heavy snow here today.  I hate winter.  And, I still have not finished the
docs for the breath contoller mod for the MOTM-850.  And there is the
"Mother of All Joystick Interfaces" for Paul calling my name... sigh....

Larry
Insert standard disclaimer

Re: [motm] Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-27 by Adam Schabtach

Something I¹ve long wondered about, but haven¹t tried, is using the flat,
black, conductive strip in a disposable anti-static wrist strap as the
resistive element in a ribbon controller. I remember reading years ago that
the stuff has a fair amount of resistance, and is reasonably uniform and
hence has a reasonably linear resistance/length relationship.

I might have one of these things in the corner of a box somewhere... Now
that I've started building a MOTM system I'm unearthing a lot of old
electronics stuff that I set aside years ago.

--Adam
(who is very happy because his first shipment of kits arrived yesterday!)

Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-27 by sucrosemusic

Well, the Kurzweil ribbon, from the outside, seems to the a bit of 
the opposite.  There's a long sheet of plastic that's creased along 
the middle, so the whole thing rides up a few millimeters along the 
middle... like an inverted trench.  Imagine keeping either a copper 
wire or your resistive element imbedded in that trench, and having 
the other end placed flat along the bottom.  you'd press down on the 
plastic, and it would smush down in the middle spot.  the stuff was 
obviously pretty resilient, though, otherwise it would wear out 
fairly quickly.

Now, I *really* don't mean to slander any company, but some past 
experiences suggest we may not want to trust the K2500-era kurzweil 
stuffs design as a model of reliability.  Still, I've never heard of 
any problems with the ribbon controller on a 2500.  (also, i've never 
seen an expressionmate)

the korg stuff has a similar approach, but instead of having the 
plastic be propped up, the wire seems to be more obviously embedded 
in the plastic, there's a ridge along it.  Although it's probably 
just cosmetic, the idea of deforming plastic to push a wire into a 
ridge underneath is a good one, I think.

--- In motm@y..., Adam Schabtach <adam@s...> wrote:
> Something I¹ve long wondered about, but haven¹t tried, is using the 
flat,
> black, conductive strip in a disposable anti-static wrist strap as 
the
> resistive element in a ribbon controller. I remember reading years 
ago that
> the stuff has a fair amount of resistance, and is reasonably 
uniform and
> hence has a reasonably linear resistance/length relationship.
> 
> I might have one of these things in the corner of a box 
somewhere... Now
> that I've started building a MOTM system I'm unearthing a lot of old
> electronics stuff that I set aside years ago.
> 
> --Adam
> (who is very happy because his first shipment of kits arrived 
yesterday!)

replacing Micro Moog Ribbon controller??

2002-03-27 by media.nai@rcn.com

Speaking of ribbon controllers, a friend of mine has a Micro Moog with a
ribbon controller that is completely destroyed.  Does anyone know of a good
replacement??  Does anyone sell them??

Re: [motm] replacing Micro Moog Ribbon controller??

2002-03-27 by ixqy@aol.com

In a message dated 3/27/02 7:43:56 AM Central Standard Time, 
media.nai@... writes:

> Speaking of ribbon controllers, a friend of mine has a Micro Moog with a
>  ribbon controller that is completely destroyed.  Does anyone know of a good
>  replacement??  Does anyone sell them??
>  


 You might try Fred Mcniff:

http://www.madbbs.com/~fmcniff/

 Andrew
 (happily soldering away on my 440 kit!)

Re: [motm] Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-28 by Adam Schabtach

> the korg stuff has a similar approach, but instead of having the
> plastic be propped up, the wire seems to be more obviously embedded
> in the plastic, there's a ridge along it.

Just curious: which "Korg stuff" are you referring to? I have a Korg
Prophecy, and its ribbon has no obvious ridge.

I have seen an Expression Mate, but only briefly and unfortunately I didn't
consider the potential for hacking it for CV applications at the time.

> Although it's probably
> just cosmetic, the idea of deforming plastic to push a wire into a
> ridge underneath is a good one, I think.

I think so, too, for reasons of durability if nothing else. Seems like a
wire would be more resilient to being deformed than the resistive plastic.

Many years ago, I remember playing with a friend's family's home organ--you
know, those 1970s-era things with the cheezy preset rhythm machines and
stuff. It had a ribbon controller thing that had a velvet-like cloth cover,
and as I recall a very positive on-off sort of feel to its action. I wonder
how it was built.

Since I'm typing this on a PowerBook, I'm suddenly curious about how
trackpads work. I think that they're capacitive rather than resistive,
though--they get all confused if your fingers are damp.

--Adam

Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-28 by sucrosemusic

Yikes!  I stand corrected, my memory was totally off on this one.  
It's not the kord ribbon i'm describing, I'm actually describing a 
shorter kurzweil ribbon, I think.  Korg ribbons are essentially 
smooth.  Sorry!

--- In motm@y..., Adam Schabtach <adam@s...> wrote:
>  
> > the korg stuff has a similar approach, but instead of having the
> > plastic be propped up, the wire seems to be more obviously 
embedded
> > in the plastic, there's a ridge along it.
> 
> Just curious: which "Korg stuff" are you referring to? I have a Korg
> Prophecy, and its ribbon has no obvious ridge.
> 
> I have seen an Expression Mate, but only briefly and unfortunately 
I didn't
> consider the potential for hacking it for CV applications at the 
time.
> 
> > Although it's probably
> > just cosmetic, the idea of deforming plastic to push a wire into a
> > ridge underneath is a good one, I think.
> 
> I think so, too, for reasons of durability if nothing else. Seems 
like a
> wire would be more resilient to being deformed than the resistive 
plastic.
> 
> Many years ago, I remember playing with a friend's family's home 
organ--you
> know, those 1970s-era things with the cheezy preset rhythm machines 
and
> stuff. It had a ribbon controller thing that had a velvet-like 
cloth cover,
> and as I recall a very positive on-off sort of feel to its action. 
I wonder
> how it was built.
> 
> Since I'm typing this on a PowerBook, I'm suddenly curious about how
> trackpads work. I think that they're capacitive rather than 
resistive,
Show quoted textHide quoted text
> though--they get all confused if your fingers are damp.
> 
> --Adam

[motm] Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-28 by Alan Wagner

How about Human conductance?

Don't laugh... My daughter has a Ring Around the Rosie doll that has a metal
disk in the palm of each hand. When she holds each hand touching the disks
the circuit is completed and the doll sings Ring Around the Rosie. You can
even have several kids linked as long as they hold hands with bare skin or
metal and the doll will work... There's also those 'touch' lamps that used
to be popular, you know the ones that you would tap anywhere on the metal
body and the lamp would turn on or off... Then there's the Bang and Olufsen
stereo equipment from the late 70's early 80's that had all touch
controls...

I'm sure all these devices used some kind of low voltage that tripped a
relay when touched. I wonder though, could we use this concept for a ribbon
controller? So instead of trying to sandwich two contact materials that
spring back apart when released, you could you have 2 resistive strips
mounted side by side with a tiny gap between them. Then when you touch with
your finger you bridge the gap completing the circuit and as you ran your
finger up and down the 2 strips resistance would be increased or decreased?
Larry mentioned that "Nichrome wire may only have 50-100 ohms in a 3 foot
piece" so would having 2 resistive strips side by side would in theory
double the resistance wherever you had your finger completing the circuit?

Since I'm not an EE I'm not sure how these circuits work or how we could do
a ribbon without zapping ourselves using it. My small brain tells me that it
is possible and would be really cool!

Still thinking!
Al
Show quoted textHide quoted text
-----Original Message-----
From: J. Larry Hendry [mailto:jlarryh@...]
Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2002 8:21 AM
To: Alan Wagner
Subject: Re: [motm] List/Controller (Long but fun)

That might work OK.  I wonder how long it would hold up?  I've got once of
those around here somewhere.  "Oh, Honey, we need a new blind.  I don't know
what happened to this one." <g>
Thanks for the tips Al.


----- Original Message -----
From: Alan Wagner <aardvark-mi@...>
To: J. Larry Hendry <jlarryh@...>
Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2002 5:42 AM
Subject: RE: [motm] List/Controller (Long but fun)


OK... Here's another one, you know those really cheap plastic window blinds
you get from Kmart? What about using the plastic slats? I just ran to all my
windows and unfortunately they are all metal and do not flex very well so I
couldn't check it out. Sounds possible. Mount your adhesive mesh to the
underside of the slat and then mount that on top of your resistive
element... And you can color coordinate with the d\ufffdcor in your home<g>!!!

Al

-----Original Message-----
From: J. Larry Hendry [mailto:jlarryh@...]
Sent: Wednesday, March 27, 2002 12:13 AM
To: Alan Wagner
Subject: Re: [motm] List/Controller (Long but fun)

Al, Thanks for the repsonse.  I have actally considered that.  But, I thingk
the downward pressure might be more than we want.  Don't want it to be too
hard to press and hold.  And, my real goal was that the ringer would
actually slide on the copper part.  Keep thinking.  I need help on this one.
The foam I mentioned is my best solution so far.
Larry


----- Original Message -----
From: Alan Wagner
Hmmm... This really odd but worth mentioning. I was at Home Depot yesterday
looking at rubber weather stripping. In particular there was one that slid
into an aluminum channel that had an upward curve along the entire length. I
wonder, if you were to use the adhesive side of you mesh to attach to the
bottom side of this weather stripping I bet it would have enough spring to
it that it would return back after pressing? You would then put your
resistive strip on (and insulated from) the aluminum channel. The one thing
that would concern me is would the material be too thick and too much
contact would made when pressed. Maybe worth checking into?
Just a thought!
Al

RE: [motm] Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-28 by Les Mizzell

> I'm sure all these devices used some kind of low voltage that tripped a
> relay when touched. I wonder though, could we use this concept 
> for a ribbon controller? So instead of trying to sandwich two contact 
> materials that spring back apart when released, you could you have 
> 2 resistive strips mounted side by side with a tiny gap between them.



I beilieve that you just described a Trautonium controller:

http://www.doepfer.de/traut/traut_e.htm




Les Mizzell

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
"Did you ever walk into a room 
and forget why you walked in? 
I think that's how dogs spend 
their lives." -- Sue Murphy 
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -   
>

RE: [motm] Re: Ribbon controller - WAS: List/Controller (Long but fun)

2002-03-28 by Les Mizzell

Ooo....

Just realised that the previous link went to the "D" site, which I didn't
have in mind.  It's still a good read though.

Try these as well:

http://www.informatik.uni-oldenburg.de/~jgspix/TRpaperEngl/TRpaperEngl.html

http://www.geocities.com/drjmschmitz/synths/traut.htm

http://www.newmusicbox.org/third-person/oct99/keyboard.html

Les Mizzell

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
"Did you ever walk into a room
and forget why you walked in?
I think that's how dogs spend
their lives." -- Sue Murphy
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.