The Mellotron and Chamberlin library for the Nordwave offer both looped and unlooped versions. The sounds are easily downloaded and organized through a simple application. I wouldn't say ,though that the wooden keyboard simulation of a real mellotron's action is cosmetic. I much prefer the action on a real tron (properly adjusted) to the Clavia. But I have listened to a variety of computer and hardware samplings of mellotrons and none are nearly as satisfying as the real thing. > --- On Sun, 7/25/10, lsf5275@aol.com <lsf5275@aol.com> wrote: > > From: lsf5275@aol.com <lsf5275@aol.com> > Subject: Re: [newmellotrongroup] Re: New Digital Mellotron > To: newmellotrongroup@yahoogroups.com > Date: Sunday, July 25, 2010, 2:17 PM > > > \ufffd > I'm skeptical as to whether there will be a huge market for it. I am > curious to hear it, though I imagine it sounds great. I just wonder what > the > attraction is? If all of the same sounds are now offered by Clavia ( I > think you > can get them uncompressed now) and the Clavia machines can play those > samples > and a jillion other sounds, then all you are buying is cosmetics. > > > The 2 Clavia keyboards that are compatible with their sample library, do > not have enough memory in either keyboard to store all the Chamberlin / > Mellotron samples not to mention the other other samples from their > library.\ufffd All the samples from the library are looped and neither the Wave > or Electro 3 have an interface as similar to a real mellotron as the NDM.\ufffd > From what I understand, sometime in the future Markus will be releasing a > new sound card with 200 additional samples that can be inserted into the > back of the NDM.\ufffd The keyboardist will have 300 sounds available; some of > these additional sounds may be looped duplicates of the 1st 100 sounds. > > > > \ufffd > I guess it really is attractive > to all of the people that really would like to have the real thing but > don't > have the money. > > There is more to it (to the average person) than the initial cost of a > brand new or completely renovated REAL mellotron.\ufffd Speaking for myself, > before buying the real thing, I would like > to see and hear a perfect working one (without having to travel out of > town) to determine whether it was right for me.\ufffd There is the risk of > shipping and having the know how to make any necessary adjustments when > it arrives and to properly service the mellotron or find a competent > technician who is capable of doing so.\ufffd Then there is the issue of the > number of sounds, the cost of new tape frames, and the storage space > required if somebody requires greater than 3 sounds. > > > > \ufffd > It would be interesting to know how many people purchased\ufffda > Clavia\ufffdkeyboard just to get the Mellotron sounds. > > > In speaking with a few people in the group about the Memotron, it was > kindly suggested that I check out Clavia keyboards.\ufffd IMO, Clavia keyboards > have a better "build quality" than the keyboards by other major > manufactures that I've seen.\ufffd If they stocked the Wave and the Electro 3 > with all the Chamberlin / Mellotron samples, I would be more tempted to > buy either or both of them. > > Robert > > > > >
Message
Re: [newmellotrongroup] New Digital Mellotron "NDM" vs. Clavia Nord Wave / Electro 3, etc.
2010-07-26 by Thomas C. Doncourt
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.