As I expected: The problem was a broken trace due to a leaked cap. Cap
exchanged, trace repaired, presets work.
Looking through ebay it seems that many of the MicroPresets sold during the
last few months had this very problem. There's one on ebay UK with this
fault right now.
There needs to be continuity from the middle pin of S6 to TR24. This is a
very long trace that goes all over the PCB. In the vicinty of C50 this
trace was almost completely missing.