Re: Review of "Electric Sound" by Joel Chadabe
2004-07-01 by Robair, Gino
*yawn* Wake me up when you folks are done... Zzzzzzzzzz
Show quoted textHide quoted text
> ---------- > From: konkuro > Reply To: wiardgroup@yahoogroups.com > Sent: Thursday, July 1, 2004 2:43 PM > To: wiardgroup@yahoogroups.com > Subject: [wiardgroup] Re: Review of "Electric Sound" by Joel Chadabe > > Just as I was saddling up my pinto to ride into the sunset, you HAD > to go ahead and post that review. > > Haven't read the book, but couldn't agree with the reviewer more. > Outside of the fact that his style is even more bilious than my own, > *jai pence,* the man is outright inspired. In a single post, he has > summed up my feeling about the electronic medium and the > academic "composeurs" (John Cage springs to mind) who have long taken > refuge in it. Had Grant offered this sooner, you guys would have been > spared a lot of suffering. :-) > > John L. wrote: > > >For some samples of superlative Electro-Acoustic music, check out > the snippets of Rick Petersen's works at the following location: > http://www.wavemakers-synth.com/wm_music.html. These get kudos from > many visitors to my web site.< > > Anybody who hasn't heard these pieces should unplug his Wogglebug(TM) > right now and hightail it to John's excellent site for a listen. I > consider these to be the best synth demos on the net. > > Grant wrote: > > >Electronic music equipment designers have created a box of > paints so enormous that you can't lift the lid anymore.< > > This is another good one. Somebody needs to write a Book of > Richterian Quotations. > > Hmmmmm... Could "Grant's Paintbox" become the next "Schrodinger's > Cat?" :-) > > There is nothing so limiting as "infinite possibilities." When you > think about it, infinity is as good as zero. That's a big reason I > have always preferred analog synths to digital synths. The > limitations they impose give you a framework in which to work. It's > like poetry. Forms such as sonnets, sestinas and haiku free the > writer by forcing him to conform to the metrical expectations of the > reader. "Blank verse," on the other hand, is simply a paragraph > arranged in an amusing way (is it any wonder that the worst poetry > invariably falls into this ubiquitous category?). > > It is prudence to remember that great painters need only a few colors > to create masterpieces. They have no need of crayons marked "flesh > tone." So it is with analog synths. Bells, whistles and gewgaws only > clutter up the paintbox. The greatest freedom lies in limitation. > > johnm > > > >