cheap plastic %$#@!
2007-03-15 by drmabuce
(sorry Professor, i just -had- to jump in on this) --- In wiardgroup@yahoogroups.com, "Grant Richter" <grichter@...> wrote: > > It is a practical idea, but the world is not yet ready for it. > i'm ready but i gave up on any hope of obtaining the 'world's' approbation decades ago, so this position doesn't really cost me anything. This appeals to me on multiple levels: It reinforces one of my pet peeves which is tremendous frustration that no sooner had the internet revealed that what i'd assumed was an anachronistic private obsession with analog circuits was in fact a nearly global phenomenon. But, as with all aspects of adult life, the other side of the sword was revealed almost immediately. i discovered to my private horror that the most popular topic of discussion would become the 'form factor'!!! The panel was the part of the module that i normally stripped off my purchases and threw away! You can imagine my incredulity when i discovered whole cults devoted to types of sockets! Oh well.... back to the fringe with me! In my minority opinion, the panel is, at best, a secondary consideration. Therefore i'm all for minimizing it's economic impedance on the creation of new designs. One of the pioneers of bang-to-buck ratio, Paia discovered early on that the only way they could hold the line on cost was to do their metalwork in-house. Nevertheless this represented a serious investment of capital and human resources. This kind of investment is not an option for a one-man show in today's economy. Fiberglass shatters. Metal bends. Pig iron requires that you use your lumbar vertebrae as a forklift. All materials have an Achilles heel. In the real-world applications of my experience** i have hauled fragile DIY electroniums to gigs with impunity. I haul factory synths too. i treat them all like antique violins and the only serious field failure i ever had was in an (unmodified) Oberheim Xpander which is wrapped in formed steel. IMHO a fiberglass panel poses no greater risk of failure in the field than any of my other gear. Fiberglass can be translucent. This affords creative, space-saving opportunities for visual feedback with LEDs In terms of electrical properties, i don't believe that a dozen or two, square inches of aluminum affords enough of a shielding advantage to justify it's cost relative to metal-traced fiberglass. There are plenty of simple shielding schemes that afford much better results than a small sheet of aluminum deployed in only one plane. This will ignite colorful and amusing tempests in the AH/Internet teapot about cheap plastic synthesizers vs 'real' metal ones....Tally Ho! However With great respect, this subject forces me to lament the untimely passing of 'konkuro' If only for the rhetorical potential....MAN! could he have torn this subject apart! Make 'em plastic, Professor! George Jetson would be proud! Zoom! -doc PS: i remember the Evenfall too! **(5% regional touring 30% local venues & the rest parked in a bedroom studio)