He he, I liked the phrase "It's easy to be a general after the battle" if it wasn't for Sequential Circuits we wouldn't have midi period,we would be stuck with DCB or 16 CV-Gate leads for an 8-voice polysynth... J On 22 Aug 2013, at 09:28, Daniel Forró wrote: > > On 22 Aug, 2013, at 3:21 PM, fulfil_objective wrote: > >> High speed sysex transfer is both desired and encouraged, for >> example, in the case of sending sound data to a sampler. If you >> wanted to send 128 megabytes of sounds to your sampler, and if you >> were restricted to 31250 bps, it would take 9.5 hours to send the >> sounds. USB MIDI devices enable higher speeds, and that speed is >> encouraged. > > Yes, in the times when nobody used USB for MIDI, SCI used higher MIDI > speed for the purpose of SDS in some of their instruments, but very > soon this idea was abandoned and manufacturers started to use SCSI > SMDI standard for sample transfers. > >> >> 31250 bps is the speed of an old dialup modem (actual throughput) on >> a good day. If you tested at 115200 bps, that is merely 3.7 times >> faster than 31250 bps. Still very slow by today's standards. > > Yes, today's standard are today's standard. Nobody knew anything about > them 30 years ago. Try to see it this way. It's easy to be a general > after the battle. > >> So yes, I think a capable modern computer with a good USB system can >> send sysex out faster than the CZ can deal with it. And it's not >> necessarily tied to CPU speed of the computer either, more like the >> speed of the whole computer-USB system. >> >> You will probably find it enlightening to read the "Universal Serial >> Bus Device Class Definition for MIDI Devices", Release 1.0, Nov 1, >> 1999, which you cand download here: >> >> http://www.usb.org/developers/devclass_docs/midi10.pdf > > Yes, but transfer between the interface and the target MIDI device > must follow MIDI standard, which is 31250 bps. Dot. > > Daniel Forro > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > >
Message
Re: [CZsynth] Speed of sysex transfer
2013-08-22 by Jason Adkins
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.