Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

PhotoShop Histograms leading us astray?

2002-03-24 by flyfishingusa2002

I have been following all the threads regarding "Combing" and "Step-
Wedges" with great interest. I have been looking at there Histograms 
in Photoshop and trying to figure out what it was telling me. I have 
been seeing a lot of "stray" information in the Histograms that 
confused me, so I decided to try the following:-

1  I did a selection of just the wedge part of the published 
standard Step wedge by Jon Cone and MIS

2  I, via PhotoShop 6, drew a simple rectangle filled with a 
graduation from 0% - 100% grey.

Neither of the above gave me a "Clean" Histogram. I fully expected 
#2 to do so. I see lots of little comb teeth and a variation in the 
histogram height when I thought it should be constant.

Could it be that the "Combing" is something that Photoshop is 
introducing and does not really appear on our finished print?

I have also noticed that on the step wedge that those little white 
dividing lines do not appear between all the steps on some 
magnifications and not on others.

I am no PhotoShop expert, but the above seems a little odd, maybe we 
are all being lead astray by PhotoShop?

Barry

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.