Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

Off topic question: good MF scanner or save for 1Ds?

2003-09-27 by Steve Kale

I have a slightly off-topic question but this group has been so helpful with all my 
other questions that I would appreciate any views from here.  I currently use 2 camera 
systems - the Contax 645 and the Canon 1N and have relatively recently stepped into 
the world of digital printing.  At the moment I have a relatively cheap scanner, the 
Epson 2450 Photo.  I have not been that impressed with the sharpness/focus of the 
scans and while they have been "ok" for my recent learning curve I can't believe that 
this is anywhere near the state of the art.  I have learnt quite a lot about sharpening 
and have been using Photokit Sharpener by Pixel Genius for a few weeks now.  
However, I still don't think the raw scans are up to scratch.  For example, I have also 
used a Phase H10 digital back in a studio setting and seen how crisp and detailed the 
images are that can be produced from a good digital capture source.

So my question now is should I upgrade my scanner to, say, a Nikon 8000 or should I 
find an interim solution (such as outsourcing the scans to a lab) and save for a digital 
capture source - for example, the 1Ds.  The Nikon 8000 costs $2,500 vs  the 1Ds at 
$8000 but can a scanner get close to a high end digital camera these days?  Or will I 
find that if I buy a Nikon 8000 it will be worth little used in a year's time and I will 
wish I had applied the money to the more expensive option in the first place, albeit 
that it might take longer to obtain?

As for digital 645, all except the newest top-of-the-line and stratosphere priced 645 
backs have a sensor size equal to full frame 35mm.  Eg the H10 has an 11 megapixel 
CCD chip with an imaging area of 36.9x24.6.  The 1Ds has about the same pixel/
image size stats yet costs about 1/3 as much.  Why does anyone not needing 22 
megapixel full frame 645 buy a 645 back when they can use the 1Ds (and even 
PhaseOne's software, CaptureOne DSLR) ?

Any thoughts would be appreciated...

Cheers

Steve

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.