Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

RE: [Digital BW] Which printer for B&W

2004-12-19 by Paul Roark

> HP Premium Plus Photo Glossy, Satin (formerly Matte) and High Gloss.
> 
> Those will give the longevity that we all desire, especially when 
> nput behind glass.
> 

This caught my eye, and I couldn't resist re-posting part of the fade test I
did in March.

After 600 hours in my tester, the 50% patch of the Epson Premium Semigloss
printed with neutral MIS UT inks then sprayed with PremierArt Print Shield
and HP paper printed with their B&W inkset had the following starting and
ending spectrophotometer readings:

Prem. SG start: C = .58, M = .57, Y = .58, Visual Density = .58

After 600 Hr:   C = .58, M = .57, Y = .58, Visual Density = .58


HP start:     C = .80, M = .79, Y = .76, Visual Density = .79

After 600 Hr: C = .78, M = .76, Y = .72, Visual Density = .77

So, while the HP B&W dyes may be very good for dyes, and maybe good enough
for most uses, I don't think they are equal to the good B&W pigments.  How
all this translates into actual fading in display I don't know.  However, if
one wants the best B&W digital print resistance to fading, I think the
predominantly carbon pigment systems are still the way to go.

Paul
www.PaulRoark.com

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.