Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

Channel Mixer and Lab L Channel

2005-11-10 by Steve Kale

I am puzzled by something I stumbled across yesterday.  I was working up an image 
converted to B&W with Channel Mixer (60% Green, 40% Blue).  I wanted to sharpen the 
image and tried a variation of the Smart Sharpen/Reduce Noise Sharpen action I use - 
specifically I copied the image, converted it to Lab Colour Mode (flattening in the process) 
and only sharpened the L channel.  I made a mistake while doing this and brought just the 
L channel of the copy over to the original as a layer.  This revealed something I found 
surprising:  the Lab Colour copy ( a flattened greyscale image) had luminance information 
in the a and b channels.  That is the luminance of the L channel alone was different from 
the luminance when all three (L, a and b) are displayed.  This would seem to fly in the face 
of what I thought the a and b channels represented.  

I did another quick test.  I took the RGB original with the Channel Mixer layer and flattened 
it, leaving a greyscale image in RGB.  Converted it to Lab.  If I uncheck either one of the a 
and b channels the image stays looking the same.  But if I uncheck both the a and b 
channels (leaving just the Lightness channel displayed) the luminance of the image 
changes significantly.

I must be missing something basic but I don't quite get it.... Ideas?

Steve

PS:  I am using PS CS2.  (My RGB space is ProPhoto RGB.)

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.