Digital BW, The Print

Folks,

Has anyone tried a neg scanning comparison between these two scanners, the
Epson 1680 Pro & Microtek 9800XL with TMA?

It would be informative to see how they each scan large format B&W film
such as 8x10".  The Microtek will scan up to 11x15", the Epson 8x10".

The both are 48 bits, with FireWire, USB1.1,& SCSI-2 and comparably
priced.

Thanks,  Stan

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! - Official partner of 2002 FIFA World Cup
http://fifaworldcup.yahoo.com

> Has anyone tried a neg scanning comparison between these 
two scanners, the
> Epson 1680 Pro & Microtek 9800XL with TMA?

> Thanks,  Stan

Hi Stan,

I've only used the Epson 1680 Pro and it scans large format 
excellently. Out of curiosity I compared the Epson to my Howtek 
4000 drumscanner - used a full density range 8x10 chrome - 
which is denser then any b+w film.

The Epson did a great job - lost a little shadow detail compared 
to the Howtek and not as sharp right out of the scanner but it 
produced a scan that could be easily massaged in Photoshop.

If I did not have my Howtek the Epson 1680 would be the way I 
would go. I was very impressed!

Hint! The Epson comes with Silverfast  - learn how to use this 
powerful scanning software to really get the most out of the 
scanner. It also comes with an IT-8 transparency to profile the 
scanner.

Best,

John V.