Great post Dieter, and for the record I love that my A-143-9 doesn't have temperature compensation. It makes for very organic changes over long periods. On Tue, Dec 2, 2008 at 5:26 AM, <yahoo@doepfer.de> wrote: > I will not participate in the emotional discussion about sine waves but > want > to mention some technical details (some of these have been already > mentioned > earlier): > > All standard VCO circuits I know are based on a sawtooth or triangle core. > When the sine wave is derived from one of these VCO cores you will never > obtain a perfect sine. The antiparallel diodes are the simplest solution to > derive a sine-like wave from a triangle, the FET circuit is a bit better > but > even far away from beeing perfect. Each kind of waveform converter is a > compromise (except rectangle). If you want a perfect sine you need a VCO > with a sine core. And in return: if you want a perfect triangle you need a > VCO with a triangle core, if you want a perfect sawtooth ... > > The A-143-9 is the only oscillator in the A-100 that uses a sine core. > Though it was not planned as a VCO but mainly VCLFO it can be (ab)used as > sine VCO. The main drawback of the A-143-9 is the missing temperature > compensation of the exponential generator. We consider to develop a sine > VCO > based on the A-143-9 circuit but with a temperature compensated exponential > generator. I expect that the price would be in the Euro 100 range. We are > also working on a VCO with sine core and linear FM with thru-zero feature. > But this is another "construction site" because the linear FM and thru-zero > feature is much more complicated than adding "only" the temperature > compensation. > > And we will point out in the module information and user's guide of A-110 > and A-111 that the sine outputs should be called more precisely > "sine-like". > But even rectangles or triangles are not perfect (each rectangle is kind of > trapezoid as each rising and falling edge has a slope that depends on the > inherent slew limiting characteristic of analog circuitry). > > Best wishes > Dieter Doepfer > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Message
Re: [Doepfer_a100] Sine wave discussion
2008-12-02 by Alex Pearson
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.