----- Original Message -----
Sent: Friday, January 21, 2005 9:12
AM
Subject: RE: [Ensoniq-VFX-SD] Is It Live
- Or Is It Memorex?
Murphy's Law - if things can go wrong, it will!
If skipping is a concern, use an iPod! More and more,
I'm seeing these performers with a Pod XT, a speaker, and an iPod. A
little goofy looking, but hey, it's a paying gig! I think it will be
fine in a band surrounding - just make sure the drummer can 'hear' the track
so they'll get the timing - same with your midi tracks.
Don't be so concerned with the technology - just don't do an
"Ashley Simpson", and blame your drummer and reflux. Although, the crowd
may get a good laugh! ...or maybe a different set list, too!
;o)
It happens to pro's, too! I've seen ZZ Top, stop in mid
song, and pick right back up, due to a broken string. I've seen Edward
Van Halen botch solo's, and he was like 'Oh well'. It is part of the
fun! Jack White from the white stripes said "I find it interesting that
a performance can fall apart at any moment" as he plays his Montgomery Ward
guitar. I thought this was a cool approach.
We use Cakewalk Sonar 4 - sign up for a clinic next time and
you'll get a great discount.
These programs and v-synths have come a long way!
That's my 3 cents!
Rodney
-----Original Message-----
From:
Michael C Lesko [mailto:MichaelL33@...]
Sent: Thursday, January 20, 2005 5:40 PM
To: Ensoniq-VFX-SD@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Ensoniq-VFX-SD] Is It Live - Or Is It Memorex?
Wow what an excellent point! I agree myself.
There's something about a "CD player" that gives me the willies. I mean
it is the same, if not better than using a sequencer it's just I get chills up
and down my spine when I think of a song "skipping" like a CD player
occassionaly does. I would much rather the whole thing just drop out in
dead silence than have to stand there like a deer caught in the headlights
while a refrain of "Girls just want to have fun" by Cindy Lauper plays over,
and over, and over.
It's all just future shock. Just like being in an
elevator we put our lives on the line with our technology. Perhaps it's
time to go low tech and start hauling around pianos again., but then again
even piano keys break. Again I think this all speaks to one of the
thrills of playing out in front of a bunch of people. How borning it
would be to know that nothing could ever go wrong. I have to think that
it only adds to the excitement of the whole thing.
Again I am looking into the CD player option. Honestly
my frustration lies in the fact that I DO have a great laptop with some
usefull programs in it, it's just that I'm not completely aware of everything
that is available on the computer for live performances. I am looking for
something that can "Switch" everything, even perhaps load a sequence from one
of my SD-1 disks too, for each song. Currently I go through a ballet at
the end of each song to press a button on my DX7II (if it's not already set up
through my SD-1) then jump over to my laptop to load in a sample, then scurry
over to my SD-1 and load in my next song
(Whew!) Somehow technology is causing me more work than
creating added benefits.
Any suggestions on software from all you seasoned pros out
there? Thanks again for the great letter Alan!
Michael
----- Original Message -----
From:
"Alan"
To:
Sent: Thursday,
January 20, 2005 11:10 AM
Subject: [Ensoniq-VFX-SD] Is
It Live - Or Is It Memorex?
Enjoying the "What A Sequencing Mess" discussion and couldn't
stand just sitting there so I thought I would throw in my two-cent theory in
the mix with hopefully an interesting side-line topic so as not to clutter
Michael's discussion....
I think there are times as musicians when we tend to
psychologically fool ourselves and give ourselves some sort of "live" playing
credibility because we have a synthesizer unit and programmed sequencer
accompanying our "live" performances. I would think we could all agree,
however, that is one of the primary purposes for the existence of synthesizers
with on-board sequencers. It certainly took our talent to create, arrange,
play, and program the sequences, but...once that is accomplished, we have
nothing more than pre- recorded keystrokes within designated patches
initiating sounds or music. There is no difference, bottom line, between that
and a CD player playing a pre-recorded piece of music during a "live"
performance. And getting to that word "psychologically" again, I do definitely
think that audience members would react very differently if they knew you were
using a CD player verses an on-board sequencer. From th! eir perspective, I
think they would throw much, much more scorn toward the CD player. But I also
think that is because they don't, for the most part, have a clue as to what a
sequencer is or what it is really doing anyway. So then...if and when you come
to terms with that, you can move on to what may or may not be more
reliable.
Let me first say with regard to my performing, I have been a
"single act" for most of my "live" performance career. There is considerable
difference between that and a band when it comes to equipment failures such as
those we are speaking about. I don't think that anything can be more reliable,
as Jay has previously mentioned in the previous topic, than a CD player with
pre-recorded material with selection and playback as easy as hitting a button.
I have owned my VFX and SD1 for almost 15 years and dearly love them both but
I would never get on stage with the dependability of my performance riding on
either one of the units, especially the VFX. I have experienced that failure a
couple of times. That's my choice of course. I use computer software to
accomplish my sequencing these days anyway so all my VFX and SD1 sequencers do
is collect dust. Although I no longer play live very often anymore, if I did I
would have to have a laptop accompan! ying me and all that goes with that
set-up or.....a CD player.
Someone might say..."Well why don't you just record the whole
performance and lip-sync it or whatever. "Well, unfortunately to the demise of
a "live" performance, you could do exactly that and some folks out there do.
And when you use sequencers or drum machines to accompany your performance you
are doing just that, just in a limited way perhaps. You are going to hit a
button on the sequencer or drum machine and play the same sounds you would
play if you hit a button on a CD player containing your pre-recorded material.
In both cases "you" are not playing any of it at the time of your "live"
performance.
So therein lays the choice you have to make in my opinion. If
you think programmed sequencers playing during "live" performances is
different in the end than pre-recorded music playing on a CD player during
"live" performances, then you will have to put your trust in the sequencer and
all that goes with it. All things considered and with a choice, it seems to me
the CD player would be the more reliable and the easiest to
back-up.
Smiley Face - Smiley Face - Smiley Face,
Alan
Yahoo! Groups Links
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor
--------------------~-->
What would our lives be
like without music, dance, and theater? Donate or volunteer in the arts today
at Network for Good! http://us.click.yahoo.com/rKxVKC/SOnJAA/n1hLAA/QnLolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Ensoniq-VFX-SD/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email
to:
Ensoniq-VFX-SD-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/