Yahoo Groups archive

Homebrew PCBs

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:05 UTC

Message

Re: [Homebrew_PCBs] Re: printer limitations or etch undercut

2007-04-11 by Adam Seychell

Andrew wrote:
> 
> 
> Does the Epson peizo print head have less
> scatter of dots than the Canon Adam uses ?
> Your photos of the 6/6 artwork certainly
> look less jaggy than Adams.

Unfortunately all inkjet printers seem to suffer the same problem. Since 
its invisible to the naked eye , printer manufactures are unlikely to 
bother improving it. All that is needed is to slow the print head by 10 
times. You may wait 5 minutes for a printout, but who cares ? I can't 
think of any applications other than for hobby PCBs. Professional screen 
printers who use inkjet printer transparencies for photomasks don't even 
need that accuracy and any PCB manufacture will use a laser photoplotter 
(3000+ dpi). So the marketers of inkjet printer manufactures aren't 
going to get any calls from customers demanding reduced line edge 
jaggedness.

If your interested, I can send you similar images produced from an Epson 
Stylus 660 printer.

> In my case the bubble etcher will fully
> etch a stripe down one side of a board in
> 1/2 the time it takes the middle of the
> board to etch.
> 

This agrees with my experience with bubble etching too. For really fine 
lines, such large etch non-uniformity is unacceptable. Another thing to 
note is Derek's test pieces had 6 mil spacing between 6 mil lines. I bet 
if one of those 6 mil lines were far away from surrounding copper then 
it will get etched faster, and therefore more undercut.

Adam

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.