Apple Logic Pro /LogicExpress Discussion

Hi all -

I'm looking for info on options for recording a (my) rock band.  Last 
time around it was done in a studio, with bass + guitars direct, drums 
recorded in the room, and scratch vocals done quietly, with everyone 
listening on headphones while playing.  I'm concerned that recording 
this way sucked a good amount of energy out of the overall recording, 
and so I'd like to try recording in the room, micing amps, etc.  
basically I'm looking for information on the range of recording options 
from these 2 extremes (everything direct vs everything live).   
wondering what effective ways maximize the live feel while recording, 
while minimizing the bleed from recording everything in one room.

I'm also in NYC, in the event anyone knows of a not-too-pricey studio 
here that has a good setup.

Thanks -

Michael

PS:  last album is at www.cdbaby.com/prankstar if anyone is curious...