Bob really raised the pole for everyone with the new PSU. Its much better mechanically and electrically, but let me just comment briefly on the socket selection. While some of this is my own conclusion, I think it's fair to say that Analogue Systems, by virtue of coming after Doepfer, was conforming to the Doepfer standards for power requirements, size, jack type, etc. This was a supremely intuitive decision on Bob's part as it created a cross platform which has unquestionably helped his sales. A brilliant move. But - for obvious reasons, he wanted to avoid using other companies PSUs if at all possible. It only makes sense. You can easily guarantee a product's performance if you can control it's operation. Once a second party product is introduced, you then lose a certain amount of control and therefore, you can no longer unquestionably guarantee the operation. I'm not speaking about the user side of the faceplate here, that's 200% compatible - I'm speaking about it's supply voltage source. I am also not dissing the Doepfer PSU. It's a fine unit, it's just not made by Analogue Systems and from a manufacturers standpoint, more of a risk. The very same holds true with Doepfer modules powered by A. Sys supplies. It will work fine - but it's not a controlled situation, that's all. So how to you design in exclusivity? You use another connector scheme and that's what Bob did. Analogue Solutions was willing to take that risk and their modules have accommodations for both the Doepfer inline and the A. Sys's DIP connections. Bob's decision to go with DIP connectors make sense as they are a cost effective functional alternative to the Doepfer scheme. You just have to be careful when connecting them, that's all. Listen, I've got hands as large as cricket mallets. It takes a bit of getting used to, but you do and it gets easy at that point. One thing I've noticed that really makes connections easier is if you remove either the top or bottom panel from the rack when making multiple connections (like when setting up your system initially), because it allows you to view things from a shallower angle so you're not covering up the area you need to see with your hand. With Bob's new power distribution panel things are much better off because he included Doepfer style terminations along with his DIP sockets on his new motherboard. He also fused the secondary side of the syste (not just the AC mains, but the DC voltsges as well) so even if ther is a problem, the chance of it doing little more than blowing a fuse is distant. just my conjecture here... - P
Message
Re: [analogue_systems] old rs15 is not well designed
2004-08-31 by Peter Grenader
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.