I'll try to answer all your questions in the morning, when I'm at a real computer... C. D. Tobie WW Product Technology Mngr. Digital Imaging & Home Theater DataColor.com CDTobie@... On Nov 17, 2008, at 10:02 AM, "madigan_bill" <madigan_bill@...> wrote: > Thanks for your quick response. At this point I am leaning towards > Spyder3 because of your/Datacolor responses to questions from this > group. (I searched the x-rite site for hours trying to get info about > Vista 64 compatibility. Found just one sentence - appears their > latest drivers do support Vista 64 - but I shouldn't have to search > for so long just to get such inadequate info. > > Still not sure about advantage of Elite - Datacolor website appears > to have little information about the advantage. > > You said Elite >> "offers L* calibration, calibearion to video standards, and more." > > QUESTION 1. What is L* calibration? > > You said >> "Pro does allow you to adjust white luminance to an appropriate > range, it just doesn't offer numerical targetting of Luminance, as > it's philosophy is to avoid numbers where possible" > > QUESTION 2. Can you give me more info about targetting luminance, and > how/why the Elite solution is superior? > > QUESTION 3. Can one uprgrade from Pro to Elite? Upgrade from either > Pro or Elite to the Spyder3 Print package? (IF not, why not? I > think x-rite offers upgrades from cheaper to more expensive, more > inclusive solutions) > > QUESTION 4. When installilng the Spyder3 software (which I assume I > will download from your site) do I need to run it in "Compatibility > mode"? or is the driver native 64-bit? > > If you are interested in the website review that mentioned > Spyder3's "Limited correction of luminance" you can email me directly > > Thanks again for your quick response. > > > > > --- In colorvision_group@yahoogroups.com, Cdtobie <CDTobie@...> wrote: >> >> Well, I'll see if I can answer this sufficiently from my iPhone... >> >> First off: EyeOne Display2 is an older generation of calibrator; > it >> has the sensors that were used in Spyder2 in it. Spyder3 has a lot > of >> technical improvements, sampling a much larger area of the screen, > at >> more color ranges, with more sensitivity, etc. >> >> Next: Elite offers a lot more than projector calibration. It > allows >> you to custom tune multiple displays to a closer match numerically, > it >> offers L* calibration, calibearion to video standards, and more. >> >> Pro does allow you to adjust white luminance to an appropriate > range, >> it just doesn't offer numerical targetting of Luminance, as it's >> philosophy is to avoid numbers where possible. >> >> Yes, luminance targetting is important with LCDs, as they are so >> bright, which requires adjustment for differing ambient luggt > levels. >> >> I'm not aware if any way that Spyder3 is limited in it's ability > to >> target luminance, within the range of luminance control the > monitor >> offers. >> >> Spyder3 products are all Vista64 capable; for quite a while they > were >> thme only calibrators that were. >> >> Sorry my answers are out of order... >> >> C. D. Tobie >> WW Product Technology Mngr. >> Digital Imaging & Home Theater >> DataColor.com >> CDTobie@... >> >> On Nov 15, 2008, at 2:14 PM, "madigan_bill" <madigan_bill@...> >> wrote: >> >>> I am about to make a purchase - can't decide if I need the Elite >>> version, or if should use X-Rite Eye-One. I currently use Spyder2 > on >>> my older machine. My new machine runs Vista 64, will be printing > to >>> an Epson Stylus Pro 3800 from CS4 >>> >>> 1.I do not need projector calibration - is that a large part of > why >>> the Elite package is so much more expensive than the Pro? >>> >>> 2.Spyder3 Pro cannot change B/W Luminance. How important is that? >>> >>> >>> 3.I read a posoting saying that luminace calibration more > important >>> for LCDs - true? >>> >>> 4.Why should I get Spyder3 Elite instead of the X-rite Eye-One >>> Dispaly 2? >>> >>> I read a review that says Spyder3 Elite suffers "Limited > correction >>> of luminance" compared to an LaCie Eye-One >>> >>> For the price of Spyder3 Elite, I could get the X-rite Eye-one >>> Display 2 calibrator - version 3.6 of the i1Match software is > suposed >>> to be Vista 64 compatible... >>> >>> >>> Thanks >>> >>> >>> ------------------------------------ >>> >>> Yahoo! Groups Links >>> >>> >>> >> > > > > ------------------------------------ > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > >
Message
Re: [colorvision_group] Re: Spyder3 Pro vs. Elite - STILL can't decide
2008-11-18 by Cdtobie
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.