Yahoo Groups archive

Datacolor User to User Support Group.

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:18 UTC

Thread

A new type of Camera Color Comparison

A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-29 by C D Tobie

This is a new way I came up with to compare the native color capabilities of various cameras, here applied to the new Canon 5D Mark lll, compared to its predecessor the Mark ll. Let me know what you think of the method, and the results.

http://cdtobie.wordpress.com/2012/03/29/color-comparison-canon-5d-mark-ll-and-mark-lll/

C. David Tobie
Global Product Technology Manager


Datacolor
5 Princess Road
Lawrenceville, NJ 08648, USA
609.924.2189
www.datacolor.com

Phone: 207.685.9248
Mobile: 207.312.0448
Fax: 207.685.4455
Email:  cdtobie@...
Skype: cdtobie

Re: [datacolor_group] A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-30 by Vampire D

Interesting comparison, I haven't got a chance to calibrate my 5D III yet myself but be curious how it comes out. I've been waiting a little bit as I am not sure if Adobe is going to make adjustments on how the 5D III is processed. It seems to do a pretty good job especially now there is native LR support.

"Do the actors on Unsolved Mysteries ever get arrested because they look just like the criminal they are playing?"

Christopher
Show quoted textHide quoted text
On Thu, Mar 29, 2012 at 6:19 PM, C D Tobie <CDTobie@...> wrote:
This is a new way I came up with to compare the native color capabilities of various cameras, here applied to the new Canon 5D Mark lll, compared to its predecessor the Mark ll. Let me know what you think of the method, and the results.

http://cdtobie.wordpress.com/2012/03/29/color-comparison-canon-5d-mark-ll-and-mark-lll/

C. David Tobie

Global Product Technology Manager



Datacolor
5 Princess Road

Lawrenceville, NJ 08648, USA


Phone: 207.685.9248

Mobile: 207.312.0448

Email: cdtobie@...

Skype: cdtobie



Re: [datacolor_group] A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-30 by C D Tobie


On Mar 30, 2012, at 2:23 PM, Vampire D wrote:

Interesting comparison, I haven't got a chance to calibrate my 5D III yet myself but be curious how it comes out. I've been waiting a little bit as I am not sure if Adobe is going to make adjustments on how the 5D III is processed. It seems to do a pretty good job especially now there is native LR support.

Yes, the native support in LR4 and/or PS CS6 are worth waiting for before profiling, unless there is a critical job, but that appears to have happened now, so we're clear of that hurdle. Further color changes seem unlikely at this point, particularly considering how similar it is to the 5D Mk ll at this point. So I figure its time to start using the calibration I generated for everything I shoot with the new body, now that I have a reasonable import path for the images.

C. David Tobie

Global Product Technology Manager



Datacolor
5 Princess Road

Lawrenceville, NJ 08648, USA

609.924.2189


Phone: 207.685.9248

Mobile: 207.312.0448

Fax: 207.685.4455

Skype: cdtobie


Re: A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-30 by johnvphoto

What's your overall impression of the 5DIII compared to the 5DII? From what I've read auto focus is deadly accurate but image quality is only touch better.

--- In datacolor_group@yahoogroups.com, C D Tobie <CDTobie@...> wrote:
Show quoted textHide quoted text
>
> 
> On Mar 30, 2012, at 2:23 PM, Vampire D wrote:
> 
> > Interesting comparison, I haven't got a chance to calibrate my 5D III yet myself but be curious how it comes out.  I've been waiting a little bit as I am not sure if Adobe is going to make adjustments on how the 5D III is processed.  It seems to do a pretty good job especially now there is native LR support.
> 
> Yes, the native support in LR4 and/or PS CS6 are worth waiting for before profiling, unless there is a critical job, but that appears to have happened now, so we're clear of that hurdle. Further color changes seem unlikely at this point, particularly considering how similar it is to the 5D Mk ll at this point. So I figure its time to start using the calibration I generated for everything I shoot with the new body, now that I have a reasonable import path for the images.
> 
> C. David Tobie
> Global Product Technology Manager

Re: [datacolor_group] A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-30 by Vampire D

I love the 5D III. 100-3200 ISO it is very similar IQ as the II but 6400 it really takes off. 12,800 is very usable. I have been shooting 6400 and lower with no post or camera noise reduction at all.

Color is a bit better than the II especially the red clipping issue. Banding issues are completely gone. The AF is awesome, servo works better than the 7D did.

Moire issues are virtually non-existing especially in video.

One of my favorite features is the new DOF button, it is in a great spot now and easy to use. I never used DOF preview before as it was so small but now I have it mapped to one-shot/servo and can instantly switch back and forth. Got some 6400 and 12,800 shots up from yesterday with my son. 12,800 has some nr the 6400 I didn't bother.

http://www.greattobedad.com/sports/soccer-time/


Show quoted textHide quoted text

On Friday, March 30, 2012, johnvphoto wrote:

What's your overall impression of the 5DIII compared to the 5DII? From what I've read auto focus is deadly accurate but image quality is only touch better.

--- In datacolor_group@yahoogroups.com, C D Tobie wrote:
>
>
> On Mar 30, 2012, at 2:23 PM, Vampire D wrote:
>
> > Interesting comparison, I haven't got a chance to calibrate my 5D III yet myself but be curious how it comes out. I've been waiting a little bit as I am not sure if Adobe is going to make adjustments on how the 5D III is processed. It seems to do a pretty good job especially now there is native LR support.
>
>; Yes, the native support in LR4 and/or PS CS6 are worth waiting for before profiling, unless there is a critical job, but that appears to have happened now, so we're clear of that hurdle. Further color changes seem unlikely at this point, particularly considering how similar it is to the 5D Mk ll at this point. So I figure its time to start using the calibration I generated for everything I shoot with the new body, now that I have a reasonable import path for the images.
>
> C. David Tobie
> Global Product Technology Manager



--
"Do the actors on Unsolved Mysteries ever get arrested because they look just like the criminal they are playing?";

Christopher

Re: [datacolor_group] Re: A new type of Camera Color Comparison

2012-03-30 by Cdtobie

>>What's your overall impression of the 5DIII compared to the 5DII? From what I've read auto focus is deadly accurate but image quality is only touch better. 

I have not shot enough to have an opinion. Auto-focus improvements are self evident, but I shoot mostly manual focus. Image quality should matter most for low light, and I haven't shot low light yet. Biggest improvements are video, and I haven't shot video yet. But it's a nice camera, for whatever that's worth. I've been away at Photoshop World and am now on deadline to finish some work, so shooting for pleasure will have to wait for this weekend. 

C. D. Tobie
Global Product Technology Mngr.
Imaging Color Solutions
Datacolor.com
CDTobie@...

On Mar 30, 2012, at 3:34 PM, "johnvphoto" <jvlist@...> wrote:

> What's your overall impression of the 5DIII compared to the 5DII? From what I've read auto focus is deadly accurate but image quality is only touch better

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.