I did some tests -- saved a "normal" performance played on my DC5A and analyzed the midi velocities... When I brought it over to my professional midi rig (playing back from LogicPro or ProTools into a GigaStudio) - the velocities were SIGNIFICANTLY lower. As in, playing ff, maximum 90-100. mf playing was more like 60-75. These velocities playback rather "wimpy" on the samplers or sound modules. Midi standards are quite open to interpretation. It has always been Yamaha's practice to have the velocity numbers be smaller than most other manufacturer's scaling. Yamaha seems to consider midi velocity 127 as 'overdriven' rather than full volume. If you record on a Yamaha system and than play on another you will need to re-scale the velocities (simple in software) to make them play as expected. Yamaha's whole method of addressing MIDI is more complicated than others ... at least thats how it was in the old days when I used to actually look at hex code for MIDI .... thankfully no more! Don
Message
Midi velocity
2004-05-22 by Don
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.