Good afternoon, everyone. To explain further: When you make a voice selection on a Clavinova, Disklavier, or other MIDI device, you are not really choosing "bass," "draw organ," or any particular sound. What you are selecting is a particular voice NUMBER in a particular voice set. So, if you choose voice 22 in a voice set called DOC, you will not get the same sound that you will get when you choose voice 22 in a GM set or an XG set. These days, if you want maximum compatibility with keyboards and tone generators that most people have, you should stick with the General MIDI (GM) voice set. If you want a broader range of voice options and are willing to forego compatibility with many playback devices, you can use XG instead. Relatively modern Clavinova CVPs and Disklaviers support the basic 480 voice XG set, as do many other contemporary Yamaha keyboards and a few from other manufacturers. When an XG file is played back on a GM instrument that does not have the XG voices, most of the voice mapping will work out reasonably well. Regards, PianoBench On Nov 23, 2007, at 12:22 PM, david962548 wrote: > Hi > > Midi IS Midi. But I would think you have a "Disk Orchestra > Collection" disk. If this is so, then the Clavinova uses a DOC map > which is NOT GM nor is it XG. If it is DOC then it has a SysEX > command in it to tell the clavinova to use the DOC map and NOT a > Midi map. > > Midi Magic > > --- In disklavier@yahoogroups.com, "kgoroway" <kgoroway@...> wrote: > > > > I always thought MIDI was MIDI, but I'm encountering some strange > > behavior. > > > > Given a Yamaha clavinova, producing a simple jazz Trio, piano on > track > > 1, drumkit on track 10, and a bass line on track 11. Plays and > sounds > > great on the Clavinova. > > > > Spit out a MIDI file, and put it on the Disklavier and the bass > line > > is gone. Look at the tracks, and it thinks that track 11 is > a "Draw > > Organ". > > > > Open the MIDI file on a PC, and it also is confused about track 11, > > but has yet another idea about what instrument is there. > > > > Any ideas? > > > > Thanks. > > -Kevin > > > > >
Message
Re: [disklavier] Re: MIDI compatibility with Clavinova?
2007-11-23 by George F. Litterst
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.