Humidity control for Disklaviers
2003-11-16 by Carol Beigel
In reply to James: > I'm in the UK - is the 42% relative humidity the same around the world, or > different for the various markets (because of the way the wood is > treated)? > > Should I be doing anything to my upright disklavier to preserve humidity? Moisture control is the bane of existence for anything made of wood - especially wood under tension and compression like a piano soundboard, or piano case and action parts where a constant dimension is required (warp prevention), or preventing the lanolin in wool felt bushings and piano hammers from drying out. Too much moisture and too little moisture will damage the piano over time. Two factors to be considered are Relative Humidity (RH) and moisture content of the wood. The ideal Relative Humidity around a piano should be a constant 42%RH. Constant is the important concept here, so don't worry if your numbers are a little higher or lower. Dampp Chaser brand climate control systems equipped with humidistats and heating rods do a great job keeping excessive moisture out of the piano by burning off the moisture before it soaks in. I am more skeptical of the value of installing the humidifier tanks, though, on these systems. Definitely NOT a good idea to have a tank of water next to the electronics!!!! If you have an upright Disklavier, have the system installed on the outside back of the piano with the humidifier tanks and cover. For grand piano Disklaviers, have several shorter rods only (no water tank!) installed underneath the soundboard with a humdistat to avoid going across the speakers and amplifier. Adding moisture to air in a room with a Disklavier is more problematic. Installing a "whole house" humidifier like an April Aire system is very effective for homes with gas forced air heat. However, homes with heat pumps don't produce hot enough air for the water to vaporize, so the water must be heated first. Where I live there are a lot of minerals in the water, so heating elements crud up very quickly and humidifier pads quickly calcify. If using a room humidifier, make sure it is at least 20 feet away from the piano. Humidifiers are high maintenance no matter what the situation - whether keeping the water tank filled or replacing or cleaning the evaporating mechanism. Because of this maintenace issue it doesn't get done often enough to maintain a constant moisture level. In real life, constant humidity control seldom exists. Evaporater pads on a furnace humidifier system should probably be changed every month or two during the winter. Room humidifiers are not filled two or three times a day. Doors and windows get opened when the temperature is comfortable. Running the air conditioning is thought to remove an adequate amount of moisture. Here in the U.S. many people heat their homes during the winter so it is comfortable to wear only a T shirt instead of a sweater. That means the RH in many North American homes gets down to 10%. On the other hand, I could have pushed my piano outside onto my deck yesterday and it would have dried out in the 29% RH. When we lost power for 5 days during the huricane the living room was reading 93% RH. Needless to say these conditions are more favorable to making a living as a piano tuner than they are for preserving the dimensions of a piano! This climate fluctuation also has a great effect on piano manufacturing. To prevent warping of the wood pianos made for the North American climate both inside and outside, wood must be kiln dried to a 5% moisture content before manufacturing a piano. This is expensive. For Europe and Asia, the climate both outside and inside is more even. Wood naturally dries to a 12% moisture content given enough time, and that is cheap to do. Hence, we have the definition of the Gray Market piano - one manufactured for a different climate than the one it is being sold because market factors of supply and demand as well as price make it look cheaper. The sales price may be cheaper but you will constantly be paying for tuning and regulation because all the wood in the piano is constantly changing dimension! I realize that my opinions concerning climate control for pianos and Disklaviers may not agree with other piano technicians, but then again I am not making a living selling humidifier tanks! Carol Beigel