I seen a picture of your setup over at ableton.com, with all due respect - the reason you're not seeing the slop other people can is down to the amount of groovebox/step sequencers you're trying to sync. http://tarekith.com/images/TarekithStudio01.jpg --- In elektron-users@yahoogroups.com, Tarekith <Tarekith@...> wrote: > > I really don't what slop everyone keeps hearing, and acting like it's > the end of the world. The MD has a little timing discrepancies, but > all my midi boxes do and it's not stopped me from making loads of > music with them. If anything, i think the MD has the tightest timing > of all my gear. I certainly can't hear the timing issues, and unless > I open up something I've recorded in my DAW and zoom WAY in, I'd never > see it either. > > ???? > > Oh well, good luck lobbying Elektron to 'fix' their timing. > > On 4/14/07, sad1robot2003 <sad1robot@...> wrote: > > Last week i purchased a SPS1-uw and fell in love with it out of the box.Playing/ > > programming it for hours on end ~by itself it has tons of character. the timing > > randomness i could FEEL right off the bat. The night before buying it i spotted the thread > > about the Timing fluctuations in the sound triggering dept. of the MDs internal > > sequencer.hmmm i thought, cant be that bad~ oh how wrong ~how high my hopes were ~ > > I syncd it to my roland orchestra of midi clock/ Din syncd drummachines and i was sadly > > aware of the Timing issue.Here is where i notice it most: i have an 808 & 909 pattern > > running in tandem , all sounds( kicks , snares , claps, hats toms etc etc are going thru the > > separate out puts on the 808 & 909. arriving into individual input channels on a healthy > > soundcraft ghost 24 LE, i like have all the individual channels up & running with the sep > > sounds all Looping and the PLAYING the mute switches making parts with combinations of > > all machines on the fly. Of course im decribing something tons of electronic musicians > > have been doing forever, no secret stuff~ but heres when the SPS 1 timing slop is really > > apparent. When you start isolating sounds I.E. an sps-1uw snare track played in tandem > > with the 808's kick and the 909s ride, that snare hits OFF about 75 % of the time. > > occasionally youll get a dead on hit and it sounds magical like the rolands do 100% of the > > time.ive been a drummer for over 20 years. my drum teacher used to have me practice to > > a metronome and my mission was to play rudiments and nail the metronome track spot > > on. when this happens , stick and click hitting at the same time theres a crack of accuracy > > that is magic. flams are flams, and thats the best way to describe what the SPS 1 is doing > > most of the time! Flaming! and have been collecting drum machines for the past 10. my > > collection is vast( tr 505,606, 808, 909, dr-110, cr-8000, cr-78, sp-12 turbo, sp-1200, > > mpc60,II, Mpc 3000 korg micro pops, kpr-77 simmons sds- 9, sds 1000, so of course > > goes w/out saying ive been looking forward to owning the machinedrum for some time > > now. On its own its fantastic ~ fluctuating and all, but when played alongside the other > > classic drummachines, i just want to mute it. sad cause i love the sounds out of it. Ive > > been following the thread close and just dont get how some people overlook the fact that > > this is a problem that needs to be solved. to pay good money for a unique modern > > machine is worth it for the sheer power of customization and control~ YET its insane that > > one of the most important features of a drum machine is its ability to play its own internal > > sounds Precisely with accurate precision, and all the power to people that are measuring it > > against MPC 60s or 3000's than by all means make those standards by which the SPS 1 > > should perform up to. recording the SPS 1 into protools i can see and measure the > > fluctuations and its a shame. My sidstations env's are sloppy . That was a BUG in the SID > > chip itself. Elektron made up for it by adding a great feature in the USER setting to have > > the choice to bypass the Buggy env's and switch it into GATE mode making arpeggios > > Super tight when played with an external seq. I hope the Elektron Guys have perked up > > their ears ~ the thread is still going on over at the Elektron group page Special thanks to > > SN interclock for steering it back to the real issue at hand~ Accurate timing. Perhaps im a > > rare bird syncing up a bunch of old drum machines and using cv/gates to trigger toms > > made on an arp 2600, or snares on a mini moog~ but i like the sounds on the SPS 1 too! > > but they are getting muted on the desk when played next to the other machines. i hope > > elektron solves the problem in the near future. i think if enough users get the point of > > what the timing complaints are really about~ theyll speak up. By all means make that > > flammy timing an OPTION on the Global page , But give me Solid timing FIRST! > > > > > > > > > > > > Yahoo! Groups Links > > > > > > > > > > > -- > Tarekith > http://www.tarekith.com >
Message
Re: THE MD SPS-1 timing debate issue
2007-04-15 by j3l1yt0t5
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.