EXS 24 Logic Sampler Users Group group photo

Yahoo Groups archive

EXS 24 Logic Sampler Users Group

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:25 UTC

Message

re:mp3/itunes

2002-02-25 by Eorthman

I've found that the mp3 format significantly affects the sound of a 
mix. Distorts the high part of the treble, emphasizes the bass, 
does something weird to the stereo image, etc. To get the best 
MP3 encoding, you really have to MIX especially for that format. 
It's the same kind of philosophy used a generation ago when 
producers did separate mixes for LP and cassette. Mixing for 
airplay also gives a number of considerations. A lot of the stuff 
you think about when mixing for radio also apply to MP3 mixing. 
A highly compressed, almost mono mix with few extreme 
frequencies works best. Some genres of music sound just as 
good as MP3 files; others always sound awful. 

That being said, I've used just about every one available for Mac 
and the best I've found is AudioCatalyst. AudioCatalyst has a 
high-frequency mode that encodes a lot of the more extreme 
frequencies that the other encoders ignore. It also has a 
normalize function which is nice for getting a sound as loud as 
possible for the radio.  

I will usually use iTunes for personal use because it's a lot 
faster, but for professional work, I'll always use AudioCatalyst. 


There are several radiostations preferring mp3 to wave.(I do not 
agree with
they're choice.) 
My search is for the best encoder there is .No matter the price.
I get well paid for delivery, and sound, not format.
If a radio prefers mp3, I try to deliver it at least at the competitors
standards.
I'm pleased if I can humor you....
My job is to deliver.....whatever format.....

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.