Yahoo Groups archive

The Logic Off Topic list

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 23:27 UTC

Thread

Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan

Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan

2001-09-24 by GAmoore@aol.com

>>I've always been under the impression that the US could have beaten Japan
>>without dropping the A-bomb.  Just like we beat Hitler. 
>>
>>But we had this new toy, and...   "let's see if it works."
>
>It's a little late to second guess that decision, considering that 
>the people who made it have been dead themselves for quite some time. 
>Dropping the two bombs certainly saved the lives of a lot of American 
>soldiers.

The US military expected to lose more in the invasion of Japan than in 
the entire European theatre. Japan would have lost 3 to 10 times as many. 
The atomic bombs were the most life-efficient way of ending the war.

Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan

2001-09-24 by dchapsk@aol.com

In a message dated 9/23/01 11:26:58 PM, GAmoore@... writes:

>The atomic bombs were the most life-efficient way of ending the war.


Thank you, Duke Nukem.

Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan--Last words

2001-09-25 by KONDO Tatsuo

GAmoore,

This is my last words on this subject.

I tried to convince you, and I thought somehow it was possible, but after 
reading your numerous posts that blame today's Japan as well as the past, 
I've found it isn't.  I trashed some posts I'd been writing.  Your 
antipathy against Japan seems unbeatable.  Even in Japanese I'm slow to 
write and read.  This discussion, although you would think I posted only a 
couple of messages, took me much time and my work has been seriously 
delayed.  You know, I thought so hard how I could convince you.  I must 
come back to making music now.

I and vast majority of Japanese truly and deeply regret what our country 
did in Korea, China and south east Asia, as well as cruelty to POWs, etc, 
etc...

But where we live now is a democratic country that rejects war by its 
constitution.

Do not generalize some points you don't like to all Japanese.

Do not drop another A-bomb on us.


Peace and Justice,

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
KONDO Tatsuo (Kondo is my family name)
website: http://www.netlaputa.ne.jp/~kndt

Re: Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan--Last words

2001-09-25 by GAmoore@aol.com

Mr. Kondo wrote:
>I tried to convince you,

Convince me of what? I have an open mind to other facts or information. 
You should understand that I have been to Japan three times, I speak some 
Japanese, I have had many Japanese friends, and even had Japanese 
students living in my house. I have stayed in Japanese homes in Tokyo, 
Osaka, Akita, and Kumamoto. So I'm no stranger to the way at least some 
Japanese think. 

I visited the museum in Hiroshima and saw the documentary movie about the 
bomb. Of course I was horrified. And I feel sorry for the victims. 
However, it is completely wrong to pick that one incident out of context, 
and not consider the rest. Unfortunately there were no photographers 
present to document the even greater loss of life and cruelty that lead 
up to those attacks. I have seen some photos, and read many accounts 
which made me sick to my stomach. All together, the entire thing is 
terrible for everyone concerned. 

I'm sorry to mention those things to you. However, most people know about 
atomic bombs, but not about the war crimes that happened before the bombs 
fell. And if you know only one thing but not the other, you will be 
biased. If you hear that a man hit a woman, it sounds terrible, but if 
you later learn that the women killed 10 people and was stabbing the man 
with a knife, then you see the whole picture, not just a tiny part of it.

Of course, most of the Japanese alive today had nothing to do with any of 
that, and there is no need for individuals like you to apologize for 
things you had nothing to do with. I don't blame you or modern Japanese. 
I'm sorry if you felt that way. You did not kill Chinese, and I was not 
alive when the bomb was dropped.

>I and vast majority of Japanese truly and deeply regret what our country 
>did in Korea, China and south east Asia, as well as cruelty to POWs, etc, 
>etc...

But you don't even know what your country did - Japan didn't commit 
atrocities in Korea or Taiwan since it already controlled those places 
(they simply forced everyone to speak Japanese and be comfort girls). 
Have you noticed that the other Asian countries, such as China, Korea, 
and Phiillipines are the ones that call for apologies, not America.

You see, this is a cultural issue. Asians are quick to apologize, but a 
sincere and heartfelt apology from your leaders is what is needed, that 
can only come from an honest look at what occurred. Then everyone can 
move on and forget it.

President Reagan apologized to the Japanese who were moved to camps 
during WWII and paid them $20,000 as I recall. 

>But where we live now is a democratic country that rejects war by its 
>constitution.

Well you're right it is. But why do the Prime Ministers continue to pay 
homage to the dead war criminals each year?

If the country is so democratic, why won't the government allow the 
teachers to teach the truth, like they do Germany. The teachers union and 
various professors want to tel the whole story but are not allowed to by 
government censorship. Why can't an average Japanese buy products made in 
the US without high tarifs?


>Do not drop another A-bomb on us.

Has anyone said one word or one hint about dropping any more bombs on 
Japan? This is totally absurd. You see, this is the true Japanese 
attitude. They are raised from childhood to believe that they were 
innocent victims and that this was some arbitary act of evil against them.

Shall I respond with "Please don't come over some Sunday morning at try 
to destroy our navy" or "Please don't go to China and kill and rape, and 
please don't torture American POWs". These comments, as silly as they 
are, are just as valid as your plea.

Please calm down, and don't take it so personal. We are talking about 
history from a time before we were born. The only reason this comes up is 
because people, quite wrongly, brought this topic up as though the US 
desserved these recent terrorist attacks because our 'crime' of bombing 
Japan.

You ask us to stop blaming Japan for what they did, but when will Japan 
and the world stop blaming the US for what it did? This topic should have 
never come up at this time.

Re: [L-OT] Re: Atomic Bomb/Japan--Last words

2001-09-25 by Kool Musick

>Mr. Kondo wrote:
> >I tried to convince you,

GA Moore wrote:
>Convince me of what?

That he is struggling hard in every way he knows to be your friend ... and 
that you have deeply and honestly hurt his feelings badly.


> >Do not drop another A-bomb on us.
Don't know about anyone else but me ... when _I_ read it I honestly thought 
he was doing his best to be amusing ...
Ah well. Maybe I've been spending too much time thinking warm and fuzzy 
thoughts about my fellow LUG'ers lately. Probably time I learned to get a grip.


>You see, this is the true Japanese attitude.
A while back you were saying how many Japanese friends you had and how well 
you knew Japan and how long you had lived there etc etc etc and how much 
you liked them, etc. And then ... this?

>Please calm down,
OK.

Kool Musick
Keep Musick Kool


_________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @... address at http://mail.yahoo.com

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.