Very well stated Doug. Some of us use the modular synthesizer as a real time control surface, whether performing or recording live, playing the knobs, not the keys. I spent three years of synth VA (Reaktor back when it was Generator) and another 10 years before that in non-realtime software synthesis (Synthia Pro on the Amiga). I found the difficulty in interacting with the VA synth in realtime to be a hindrance. My music was lacking spontaneity without a one to one mapping of knob, switch, LEDs and other controls to the actual synthesizer. I have an Encore Slidemate for the VA, but it can't match the ergonomics of an entire analog modular system. And from the sound of it, I would love to hear some of your music! John Loffink The Microtonal Synthesis Web Site http://www.microtonal-synthesis.com The Wavemakers Synthesizer Web Site http://www.wavemakers-synth.com > -----Original Message----- > From: Doug Pearson [mailto:jasret@mindspring.com] > > > >Only because there was no practical choice at the time. Modulars on > >stage are essentially window dressing. And that is NOT a troll. > > Not taken as one, it's a very legitimate assertion (bands LOVE it when I > bring the Wiard with all the flashing lights). But it should be clear by > now that our musical interests are very different, perhaps to the extent > that's what is a valuable tool to me might be worthless epherma to you > (and > vice-versa). > > For me, the analog modular synthesizer (especially in the Wiard format) is > the ultimate performance tool. Granted, I could do most of what I do with > one with an analog monosynth or decent VA (perhaps I'm the only person who > hears the difference, but since I am not a professional, who am I making > music for except myself?). But neither of those allows me the freedom to > spontaneously create such a broad array of sonic textures (generally not > notes - but never say never). Like I said, you wouldn't like what I do, > which I can best describe as being the "bug" musician in a rock (or > "improv") band, interacting with other musicians in real time. And yeah, > for that purpose, I use the dual joystick controller (an integral part of > the overall Wiard *system* - an aspect of the Wiard that several people > have commented on that IMHO sets it above the other modulars, in my > experience, excellent as they are), no keyboard, don't give a rat about > tracking (but visual feedback - in the form of flashing leds - really > helps > on dark stages). I have even also successfully used it to play melodies > in-tune in the studio :^). To me, for performance purposes, "modular > synth" is as legitimate a choice as violin, "keyboard", bass, guitar, > "electronics", monosynth, piano ... all different instruments (that I can > more-or-less play) which have their own individual uses. > > But modular synthesizers have a lot of uses, more than just what I use > them > for (and I haven't even begun to describe all the things I use them for). >
Message
RE: [wiardgroup] Re: Please support Original Design
2004-06-29 by John Loffink
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.