SEAMUS Newsletter (a BIG Thank You to John Loffink)
2007-11-01 by Grant Richter
Please see John Loffinks article in this month's SEAMUS newsletter: http://www.seamusonline.org/ Also please see: http://www.seamusonline.org/luening.html about Otto Luening, whom I was fortunate enough to have had lunch with at the tender age of 18 (at the invitation of my mentor August Wagner). Mr. Luening was a most gracious and kind person, kind enough to tolerate the presence of a really ignorant 18 year old. He stopped by the University while visiting family in Milwaukee. Luckly, I was so awestruck I shut up and listened carefully. Remembered indirect quotes from that lunch: "We originally wanted to be able to patch a tape recorder input or output directly to anything, that is why we specified a 1 volt peak to peak signal level for all devices. (like the Buchla 100 and 200 and Moog 900 series) we soon realized that subtractive synthesis, subtracted audio power, and so signal to noise ratio degraded rapidly. That is why we were happy to see later instruments using a 10 volt peak to peak standard, which allowed more signal processing while preserving acceptable signal to noise ratio." (He did not specify if Columbia-Princeton buying specifications were involved in the change. Bear in mind that for a time, Columbia-Princeton WAS the biggest marketplace for electronic music synthesizers, their buying specifications significantly affected early synthesizer). Otto Luening ruefully paraphrasing Vladimir Ussachevsky: "Bob Moog called one day and asked if they wanted to make an envelope generator with more than two segments, what should the extra segments be? I walked into my office and found an book that referenced attack, decay, sustain and release, which I told Bob about. Had I known it would become an industry standard, I would have thought about it for more than 10 seconds!".