Very well put! Finally a detailed examination of rubber vs mesh without any bias. I thought I was the only one who loved Yamaha pads. Just to put my two cents into the pot. I've been drumming for over 20 years. Ten on and off the road playing night after night. I still practice as much as time allows as I have a day job, and cannot play as much due to family responsabilities. I hope that qualifies me to post about something so personal as how the pad plays and feels. My openion and a buck twentyfive will also get you a cup of coffie. I play my TP-120 every day, sometimes up to 3 hours. You would think a "rubber" pad would become annoying after three hours but it plays so well it's like playing a top quality drum. I hate going to bed because I want to keep playing the darn thing. The same DTX kit is in the music store beside a TD-8 kit. Not to poo poo on Roland who I have great respect for, but DTX vs TD-8, no contest. Xtreme hands down winner. Roland has a bigger following, and that's fine with me, but the Xtreme is very under rated. The entire line of DTX samples and modules, under rated. Why? Under hyped. I am getting off topic, sorry. The samples of the Xtreme and triggering is top notch. The TD-8's have a over processed sound that just do not sit right in my ears. do not take my word on anything, try it for yourself and make an educated evaluation. The xt's rock en roll sound wise. Getting back on topic, the pads, they are rubber, and they look like little space ships with a red knob. Playing those babies live with the thunder rocking out of the PA, I say, who cares? I forget all about the space ship look, and rubber vs silent mesh. It feels real, sounds real and pounds real good through the PA. I've yet to play on the TD-20's so I cannot comment about them. I own mesh drums with Roland heads and cannot get into the bouncyness of mesh. I love the look of Hart pads though. I know we are not into Roland bashing here thank goodness. With that said, hopefully the TD-20's are as good as everyone is saying as it only makes Yamaha work harder to make better modules. I would add pads, but the TP series of pads are TOPS! I personally love my xtreme drum samples and wish I had a D Drum and TD-20 beside my module to test those unit's sounds.
Message
Re: DTXtreme2S and Roland TD-20
2004-08-11 by drumsonly2002
Attachments
- No local attachments were found for this message.