Digital BW, The Print

What follows is Dan Margulis's report of ADOBE's response. To cut to the
chase: Of course they've failed completely to answer the all important
question of why they gave no a priori notice of the new "feature."



"

Folks,

The following was posted at Adobeforums this evening by Kevin Connor, a
prominent member of the Photoshop team, in response to the concerns
expressed over the anticounterfeiting technology incorporated in Photoshop
CS.

Dan Margulis
_______________________

As someone at Adobe who was involved in the decision to include counterfeit
deterrence in Photoshop CS, let me finally provide you with a response 
to all
of these concerns and questions. Sorry for the delay!:

Photoshop CS does indeed include a counterfeit deterrence system (CDS) to
prevent the illegal duplication of banknotes. The CDS was created by a
consortium of central banks from around the world. We, along with other
hardware and software manufacturers, have included CDS in our products at
their request to address the threat posed by the use of digital 
technologies in
the counterfeiting of banknotes. There are other software products from 
other
companies that already use this same technology. There are also hardware
products that use the same or similar technology. For example, most color
copiers sold today will not allow you to copy currency.

As digital imaging technology advances, becoming more broadly available
and user friendly, the old barriers to currency reproduction are 
becoming less
effective. The unscrupulous are taking advantage of the functionality 
that is
being provided to the vast majority of honest users for the purposes of
counterfeiting currency. In the US and around the world, counterfeiting
through digital means is increasing exponentially, and retailers and the
general public--including our own customers--are at risk.

Counterfeit currency is essentially a hot potato. Whoever holds it last, 
loses.
The person who loses isn't necessarily the counterfeiter. There's no
government body in place to "reimburse" people who, through no fault of 
their
own, get paid with currency that turns out to be counterfeit. In our
implementation of CDS, we've worked very hard to balance the need to
protect these unsuspecting victims of counterfeiting along with the need to
continue to provide a product that efficiently does what honest customers
need it to do.

There appear to be several major concerns and objections repeated
throughout this message thread, so I'll try to address each one 
individually:

1. Performance: CDS does not cause any noticeable slowdown in Photoshop
performance. During most operations performed in Photoshop, CDS is not
used at all. When it is used, the performance impact often is just a 
fraction of a
second.

2. Legal use of notes: It is true that the current implementation of CDS 
will
prevent you from scanning in your own banknotes even if your usage 
intent is
entirely within legal boundaries. Regulations for using banknote images 
vary
by country. It is the responsibility of the central bank in each country 
to provide
images that can be used within the legal guidelines of that country. In 
other
words, if you want to legally reproduce images of the new $20US bills on a
Web site or in a marketing brochure, you can contact the U.S. Bureau of
Engraving and Printing for legal images that can be opened and manipulated
in Photoshop CS. (You can visit them at www.moneyfactory.com.) Similar
solutions should be available in other countries. If you find that your 
central
bank is not providing adequate support to permit legal uses of their 
banknote
images, then you should let them know.

3. Adobe's intentions: Please be assured that this implementation of CDS is
not a step down the road towards Adobe becoming "Big Brother." We know
that one of the reasons people love Photoshop is because it's an incredibly
flexible tool that can be used for so many different things. That's also 
one of
the reasons we at Adobe enjoy working on new versions. Finding ways to
prevent you from doing things in Photoshop really doesn't interest us!

Moreover, the CDS is not Adobe technology, but was provided by the central
banks, who would have no reason to want to restrict anything other than 
bank
notes. Counterfeiting is really a special case in which we could see how 
our
own technology advances were making it easier to commit crimes and we
were asked to implement a solution that would have minimal impact on
honest customers. Yes, there is some impact, in that you need to contact 
your
central bank for images, but our hope is that it's not a huge 
inconvenience for
that small group of customers who do need to reproduce these images in 
their
graphic design work. It also provides the central banks with an 
opportunity to
better educate customers on exactly what is and isn't legal usage.

Of course, CDS in Photoshop CS is essentially a 1.0 implementation of a
feature, analogous to the state of the layers palette in Photoshop 3.0. We
realize that there may be room for improvement, particularly if there 
are corner
usage cases that weren't taken into account in our current designs. We do
want to hear about your concerns, and we definitely want to hear if 
there's a
specific problem that this implementation has created for you. As with any
Photoshop feature, we depend on hearing from customers so that we can
make continual improvements release after release. "








Keith Krebs

"Just some guy," caretaker of the Multiverse's largest EPSON printer
User Community (highly recommended by Vogon Poets and MegaDodo
Publications), at:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/EPSON_Printers/
and  the Multiverse's largest Canon printer User  Community at:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Canon-printers
"For the rest of you out there, the secret is to bang the rocks together
guys"



****************************************************************
CONFIDENTIALITY & COPYRIGHT NOTICE:
This e-mail message, including attachments and contents, is \ufffd Copyright,
Keith Krebs, 2001-2004, All Rights Reserved. It is expressly for the
sole use of the intended recipient and may contain confidential and
privileged information. Absent the express written authorization of the
author, any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, transfer, or
distribution is explicitly prohibited and taken at your own risk. If you
are not, or are unsure whether you are, the intended recipient, please
contact the sender immediately and destroy all copies of the original
message. Violations will be prosecuted to the FULL extent allowed under
applicable civil and criminal law. Imagery published or distributed in
violation of these conditions shall be subject to a $1500/image
liquidated damages charge, in addition to any applicable Copyright
violation penalties.


****************************************************************
{ The P.O.V. Image Service Website is still at http://www.p-o-v-image.com/ }