Yahoo Groups archive

Digital BW, The Print

Index last updated: 2026-04-28 22:56 UTC

Message

RE: [Digital BW] [OT] ADOBE's Response

2004-01-09 by Tim Atherton

> Hi Tim,
>
> But...even at that, putting it in Adobe is moot.  BTW, older scanners are
> easily available...and the documentation of the command sets for scanners
> are readily available (and certainly easily reverse engineered via a SCSI
> bus analyzer)...and even at that, developing a scanner isn't
> really a *big*
> deal, when you're talking minting millions of dollars, so unless
> it's built
> into the linear sensor, which is obviously silly, all there preventing is
> you and I from printing our own money, which I doubt is a
> significant source
> of counterfeiting...but hey, if it makes them feel more secure
> (kind of like
> locking your screen door ;-), who am I to question it.
>
> Regards,
>
> Austin

I know - the only people I can see this discouraging and possibly stopping
(and even that is doubtful) are the teenage and Mom and Pop counterfeiters -
kids doing at school or home, people who think - hey this Epson prints
pretty well, I could make a few dollars. And although you often see news
reports about them, I very much doubt this is a serious percentage of the
fake moolah out there.

Meanwhile, it inconveniences legit users of course. I posted on another list
how a Photo Editor friend discovered this "feature" recently, before all the
hoopla.

There were counterfeit notes in their community so they did a story on it.
With the  local PD and the Secret Service, they got a bunch of the
counterfeit notes and had the cops do a compare and contrast - this is what
to look for etc.

Well, when they tried to open the images their photog had taken, half
wouldn't open - even one where the note was fairly small being held by a
cop. So, they wasted time trying to figure out what was wrong - digital
camera malfunction? corrupted image file? photoshop problem? Fiddling around
going WTF. They finally figured out basically what it was then had to find a
work around (which was easier - PS7). So, here is an entirely legitimate
use, actually working with law enforcement and the Secret Service, and this
hidden "feature" cost them time, money and frustration. Way to go Adobe.

tim

Attachments

Move to quarantaine

This moves the raw source file on disk only. The archive index is not changed automatically, so you still need to run a manual refresh afterward.