Mellotronists

I agree Bernie.  That's why I sent it.
If Rush and Tool are "Prog", why isn't Led Zepplin?

I'm sure we could all make a list of recordings that are missing from
the list.  Everyone has a different idea about what "prog" is.

Here's my bizarre brian dump:

Hackett and Gabriel solo material?  (Kind of proggy!)
10CC - How Dare You or Original Soundtrack?  (Quite progressive!)
Ultravox - Vienna?  (totally prog!)
Brian Eno - Before and After Science?  (beyond prog)
The Tubes - Remote Control?
ELO's Eldorado?
Early Bowie?
Todd Rundgren - Todd or A Wizard a True Star?

I could go on and on...

Clay

I think Clay has the correct take on matter. It would be a dull world if (in 
this case for example) we all agreed on the definition of progressive rock 
let alone the specific artists.
To each their own comes to mind. And I could go on and on too which drives 
home the point.

Tony
#510
----- Original Message ----- 

From: "ceccles_ca" <clay123@...>
To: <Mellotronists@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2005 12:12 PM
Subject: [Mellotronists] absurd list


>I agree Bernie.  That's why I sent it.
> If Rush and Tool are "Prog", why isn't Led Zepplin?
>
> I'm sure we could all make a list of recordings that are missing from
> the list.  Everyone has a different idea about what "prog" is.
>
> Here's my bizarre brian dump:
>
> Hackett and Gabriel solo material?  (Kind of proggy!)
> 10CC - How Dare You or Original Soundtrack?  (Quite progressive!)
> Ultravox - Vienna?  (totally prog!)
> Brian Eno - Before and After Science?  (beyond prog)
> The Tubes - Remote Control?
> ELO's Eldorado?
> Early Bowie?
> Todd Rundgren - Todd or A Wizard a True Star?
>
> I could go on and on...
>
> Clay
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>
>
>
>

Dear All,
 
Gentle Giant had it right with the giant illuminated sign that flashed  
"prententious" behind them in giant letters at the correct part of the set  (during 
Knots if I remember correctly).
 
...and why are Garden Shed missing from 'the list'...
 
All the best,
Norm

In a message dated 28/08/2005 23:00:41 GMT Daylight Time, lsf5275@...  
writes:

You  mean,"England," right Norm?
Of course I did, I was asleep while replying to my e-mail...
 
 
zzzzzzzzzzzz
 
Norm