Bc2000 (for the BCF2000 & BCR2000)

I find this is an annoying flaw in assigning controllers to Ableton Live 
knobs and sliders.  Movements in Ableton and saved positions should 
output on the control channel!  One of the reasons I bought the 
Behringer was that it has the lights which show the position of the 
controllers.  It works with the Mackie mode but I want to set it up 
differently.  One can use different takeover modes, but it's not a great 
solution as the knobs often don't react immediately.  The best solution 
I've come up with so far is to generally work in immediate update mode 
and then go into takeover mode (with a saved preset on the BCR) for live 
work.

The MIdevice plugin wrapper looks like it might solve this problem for 
VST devices, but it's not a solution for the volume faders.

Anyone know where Ableton are at with addressing this issue?

John


Robert Krueger wrote:
>
> I'm primarly a user of Ableton Live. Any VST capabable plugin
> parameter can be midi learned. It's as simple as turning on Midi Learn
> in Ableton, selecting the parameter you wish to be controlled, and
> then tweak the knob, slider, button on your controller.
>
> I used to use Cubase SX2 and it had a similar feature, so find out in
> your Cubase manual how to do midi learn on the parameter and tweak
> your knob.
>
> Most VSTis do not send midi out from my experience, so doing the learn
> in reverse is not likely to work for you.
>
> On Tue, Dec 23, 2008 at 5:03 AM, ivaasura <Sunrider7@... 
> <mailto:Sunrider7%40gmx.de>> wrote:
> > --- In bc2000@yahoogroups.com <mailto:bc2000%40yahoogroups.com>, 
> steve <stevesblues@...> wrote:
> >>
> >> I suspect not Robert.
> >> Can i assume all the vsts i have are incapable of doing so or is some
> >> setup required 1st in the host - cubase ?
> >
> > If your VSTs do not provide MIDI learn, this could be a solution for
> > you: http://www.midevice.com/News.aspx 
> <http://www.midevice.com/News.aspx>
> >
> >
>
>